Round 8 Lodgement Threads

[JBs-Hawks]

Def: Frawley 77 - Broadbent 58 - CPearce 50

Mid: Beams (VC) Sidebottom Bastinac Johnson

ruck Phillips 49

FWDS: Riewoldt - Breust 71 - wingard 112

int  Scully 110 Simpkin 94

emg ellis 37 sub cheney 82

[ossie85]

I vote to get rid of loopholing next year. Just assumed it was frowned upon.

how would you do that whatlez? Just the one lock out?  Or leave it to ringo's discretion?

All players you name on field must be named in Thursday/Friday teams (based on the time the teams were submitted)

Then if somebody names somebody not named (attempts to loophole) they only get covered at 1/2 points.

This. Pretty basic, not sure if Ossie didn't know the answer or was serious.

Well, that does not work.

Ringo already only has a single lockout which works for most rounds

But this split round the other 6 teams haven't even been named yet

[Justin Bieber]

I vote to get rid of loopholing next year. Just assumed it was frowned upon.

how would you do that whatlez? Just the one lock out?  Or leave it to ringo's discretion?

All players you name on field must be named in Thursday/Friday teams (based on the time the teams were submitted)

Then if somebody names somebody not named (attempts to loophole) they only get covered at 1/2 points.

This. Pretty basic, not sure if Ossie didn't know the answer or was serious.

Well, that does not work.

Ringo already only has a single lockout which works for most rounds

But this split round the other 6 teams haven't even been named yet

Basically you just don't captain someone who is named for week 2

[ossie85]

I vote to get rid of loopholing next year. Just assumed it was frowned upon.

how would you do that whatlez? Just the one lock out?  Or leave it to ringo's discretion?

All players you name on field must be named in Thursday/Friday teams (based on the time the teams were submitted)

Then if somebody names somebody not named (attempts to loophole) they only get covered at 1/2 points.

This. Pretty basic, not sure if Ossie didn't know the answer or was serious.

Well, that does not work.

Ringo already only has a single lockout which works for most rounds

But this split round the other 6 teams haven't even been named yet

Basically you just don't captain someone who is named for week 2

That punishes those with players like Ablett and Pendlebury.

[Justin Bieber]

I vote to get rid of loopholing next year. Just assumed it was frowned upon.

how would you do that whatlez? Just the one lock out?  Or leave it to ringo's discretion?

All players you name on field must be named in Thursday/Friday teams (based on the time the teams were submitted)

Then if somebody names somebody not named (attempts to loophole) they only get covered at 1/2 points.

This. Pretty basic, not sure if Ossie didn't know the answer or was serious.

Well, that does not work.

Ringo already only has a single lockout which works for most rounds

But this split round the other 6 teams haven't even been named yet

Basically you just don't captain someone who is named for week 2

That punishes those with players like Ablett and Pendlebury.

Oh I said it wrong, basically captain someone who is NAMED EITHER WEEK ONE OR WEEK TWO.

Oh looks there whatlez' side. Their vice captain is Dion Prestia and cause Dion scored 200, let's make Beau Waters captain even though he's out for the season.

#logic

[ossie85]

I vote to get rid of loopholing next year. Just assumed it was frowned upon.

how would you do that whatlez? Just the one lock out?  Or leave it to ringo's discretion?

All players you name on field must be named in Thursday/Friday teams (based on the time the teams were submitted)

Then if somebody names somebody not named (attempts to loophole) they only get covered at 1/2 points.

This. Pretty basic, not sure if Ossie didn't know the answer or was serious.

Well, that does not work.

Ringo already only has a single lockout which works for most rounds

But this split round the other 6 teams haven't even been named yet

Basically you just don't captain someone who is named for week 2

That punishes those with players like Ablett and Pendlebury.

Oh I said it wrong, basically captain someone who is NAMED EITHER WEEK ONE OR WEEK TWO.

Oh looks there whatlez' side. Their vice captain is Dion Prestia and cause Dion scored 200, let's make Beau Waters captain even though he's out for the season.

#logic

An element of risk still remains.  Prestia could score 45, so you name John Smith captain but he later pulls out, and your stuck with Prestia

How are you meant to know if the player you name week 1 as captain will actually be named week 2? You suggesting you should be then forced to name a spud as captain because all the other players are locked?

What about emergencies?

just needs to be thought through whatlez,  far from basic as you suggest

[Justin Bieber]

Why don't we either not play through byes or play 3 games and rub out the North vs South?

[ossie85]

Why don't we either not play through byes or play 3 games and rub out the North vs South?

because with 18 teams you can't avoid the bye

And you may as well just flip a coin if you play with 6 afl teams missing each round

it works fine as it is

this way you have 17 rounds with 18 afl teams available

you add bias any other way

[Vinny]

Oxford Owls

Defenders: Sean Dempster, Rhyce Shaw, Kade Kolodjashnij, Dustin Fletcher.
Midfielders: Jack Steven, Scott Thompson, Mitch Duncan, Andrew Swallow.
Rucks: Hamish McIntosh
Forwards: Daniel Giansiracusa, Sam Mayes, Jeff Garlett, Sam Lloyd.
Utilities: Oliver Wines, Jeager O'Meara.

Emergency: Sharrod Wellingham (S)(M) - Easton Wood (D) - Aaron Black (F)
Captain: Jack Steven
Vice-Captain: Oliver Wines.

Defenders: Sean Dempster 59, Rhyce Shaw 65, Matthew Jaensch, Dustin Fletcher 79.
Midfielders: Jack Steven 158, Scott Thompson, Mitch Duncan, Andrew Swallow.
Rucks: Hamish McIntosh
Forwards: Daniel Giansiracusa, Sam Mayes 77, Jeff Garlett 22, Taylor Walker.
Utilities: Oliver Wines 145, Jeager O'Meara.

Emergency: Sharrod Wellingham (S)(M) 97 - Easton Wood (D) - Aaron Black (F)
Captain: Jack Steven
Vice-Captain: Oliver Wines.

Players in italics have been locked out, other changes have been made.

Sharrod Wellingham comes on for Jeffy Garlett.

[kilbluff1985]

Hearing Swallow might be back this week Vinnamon ;D

[Vinny]

Ya :D

[LF]

Nottingham Hoods

Backs: Heath Grundy(83),Harry Taylor,Andrew Walker(79),Lynden Dunn(75)
Mids: Scott Pendlebury,Dan Hannebery(190),Matt Rosa(108),Chris Masten(130)
Ruck: Aaron Sandilands(110)
Forwards: Robbie Gray(145),Sam Day,James Podsiadly,Jesse White
Utilites: Jackson Macrae(89),Aaron Young(40)
Emergencies: Andy Otten(F),Tom Langdon(B)(Sub),Jamie Bennell(66)(M)Dawson Simpson(R),

C: Scott Pendlebury
VC: Dan Hannebery
EVC: Chris Masten

1049/10

Will be taking Hanners as C tho :P

[jhello]

Leeds Leeches

D: Michael Johnson (79), Nick Malceski (91), Jeremy Laidler (49), Alex Silvagni (55)
M: Luke Shuey (100)(VC), Lenny Hayes (144), Farren Ray (96), x
R: x
F: Mark LeCras (126), Jeremy Howe (99), Adam Schneider (152), x
U: Dom Tyson (162), Jack Viney (133)

E: x, Matt White (M)(sub)(96), Fletcher Roberts (F)(44), x

1286 / 12

D: Michael Johnson, Nick Malceski, Jeremy Laidler, Alex Silvagni
M: Luke Shuey (VC), Lenny Hayes, Farren Ray, Brett Deledio (C)
R: Sam Jacobs
F: Mark LeCras, Jeremy Howe, Adam Schneider, Charlie Dixon
U: Dom Tyson, Jack Viney

E: David Mackay (D-OOP) , Matt White (M)(sub), Fletcher Roberts (F), Sam Kerridge (R-OOP)

[LF]

Nottingham Hoods

Backs: Heath Grundy(83),Harry Taylor,Andrew Walker(79),Lynden Dunn(75)
Mids: Scott Pendlebury,Dan Hannebery(190),Matt Rosa(108),Chris Masten(130)
Ruck: Aaron Sandilands(110)
Forwards: Robbie Gray(145),Sam Day,James Podsiadly,Jesse White
Utilites: Jackson Macrae(89),Aaron Young(40)
Emergencies: Andy Otten(F),Tom Langdon(B)(Sub),Jamie Bennell(66)(M)Dawson Simpson(R),

C: Scott Pendlebury
VC: Dan Hannebery
EVC: Chris Masten

1049/10

Backs: Heath Grundy(83),Harry Taylor,Andrew Walker(79),Lynden Dunn(75)
Mids: Scott Pendlebury,Dan Hannebery(190),Matt Rosa(108),Chris Masten(130)
Ruck: Aaron Sandilands(110)
Forwards: Robbie Gray(145),Sam Day,James Podsiadly,Andy Otten
Utilites: Jackson Macrae(89),Aaron Young(40)
Emergencies: Jesse White(F),Tom Langdon(B)(Sub),Jamie Bennell(66)(M)Dawson Simpson(R),

C: Andy Otten
VC: Dan Hannebery
EVC: Chris Masten

[Justin Bieber]

D: Pearce Hanley (115), Trent McKenzie, Greg Broughton, James Gwilt (60)
M: Michael Barlow (238), Ryan Griffen (143), Trent Cotchin, Nick Dal Santo
R: Will Minson (121)
F: Chris Mayne (94), Shaun Higgins (67), Jack Darling (102), Brandon Matera
U: Clint Jones (110), Dion Prestia
S: Paul Poupolo (106)

Emg: Dominic Cassisi (MID), Andrew Mackie (DEF), Tom J Lynch (FWD)