Is Travis Cloke the biggest potato in the AFL?

[Nige]

Cloke and Petrie are shells of what we expect them to be normally.

[Mailman the 2nd]

Cloke gets 1 closer to the coleman.

In other news, he still sucks

[Vinny]

24SC, what a superstar.

[ossie85]

Honestly guys, he's lead the Contested Mark category for the previous 5 years, made the All-Aus team twice, 2nd in the Coleman once and won a Premiership.

He's having a stinker this year, but Spud is just crazy talk. Look at Tomahawk last year, was terrible.

[Nige]

Honestly guys, he's lead the Contested Mark category for the previous 5 years, made the All-Aus team twice, 2nd in the Coleman once and won a Premiership.

He's having a stinker this year, but Spud is just crazy talk. Look at Tomahawk last year, was terrible.

Funny how nobody has uttered a word about Petrie.

Having an equally bad year as Trav.

That said, Trav should take a train home, might be able kick 11 next week.  ;D

[ossie85]

Honestly guys, he's lead the Contested Mark category for the previous 5 years, made the All-Aus team twice, 2nd in the Coleman once and won a Premiership.

He's having a stinker this year, but Spud is just crazy talk. Look at Tomahawk last year, was terrible.

Funny how nobody has uttered a word about Petrie.

Having an equally bad year as Trav.

That said, Trav should take a train home, might be able kick 11 next week.  ;D

Or JJK minus the Giants effort

[Mailman the 2nd]

Honestly guys, he's lead the Contested Mark category for the previous 5 years, made the All-Aus team twice, 2nd in the Coleman once and won a Premiership.

He's having a stinker this year, but Spud is just crazy talk. Look at Tomahawk last year, was terrible.

Tom Hawkins had dislocated discs in his back and could hardly pick up the ball, that said I would hardly be suprised if Cloke didn't either with his performance.

He almost cost his team the only premiership they've had in recently.

If he didn't have blokes like Swan, Pendlebury and Beams literally handing the ball to him on a platter, he wouldn't have more than 200 career goals

[ossie85]

Boo hickey.

[kilbluff1985]

Cloke is a spud

Think that's what you meant

[Vinny]

Cloke is a spud

Think that's what you meant

[ossie85]

People have come on with a negative idea (something I'm never a fan of to begin with), they have decided on an opinion and are selectively picking evidence to support its argument.

I can show all the raw stats and logic and common sense but it isn't going to change anyone's opinion

Clearly Cloke isn't the worse player in the AFL

Clearly he is having a poor year

[Nige]

How's Carlton's big key forward going Vin?

[T Dog]

How's Carlton's big key forward going Vin?

Daisy?

[Vinny]

How's Carlton's big key forward going Vin?

Better than Cloke. But anyone is going better than that guy.

[Nige]

How's Carlton's big key forward going Vin?

Better than Cloke. But anyone is going better than that guy.

Dunno about that.