Sam Gray or Nick Robertson

[maygs]

Planning on trading out Ellis this week.  Want to downgrade to a bubble boy so I can bring in NRoo.

The question is who to bring in - Gray or Robertson.

My concern with Robertson - who I see as scoring better and therefore making more money - is that I already have Aish & Taylor.

My mids are currently:
Ablett, Pendlebury, Rockliff, Polec, Tyson, Dunstan, ELLIS, Aish (Taylor, Gleeson)

FWDS:
Danger, Roughie, Zorko, Wright, May, Fasolo, (Close, Thurlow - 'cause I've got Mummy on the bench and Hale as R2 until Mummy's back)

Was always planning on trading Hale for NRoo (once he dropped in cost), but now thinking of Roughie??  Or should I bite the bullet and trade out Hale and Mummy?  (for Jacobs & NRoo and leave the bubble boys for a while?)

[ClarksonsArmy]

Robertson has better JS

Get your round 8 premiums in round 9 for round 8 rookies upgrades..

Gary had 1 good week, monfires comes back he goes out

[GoLions]

Robbo > Gray

Doubt Gray will keep his spot when Monfries comes back, whereas Robbo has really good JS with Rich gone for the season

[maygs]

Thanks guys.

Just to confuse the thread a little more:-

What about Ellis -> Crouch ??

Still gives me the money I need for Roughie -> NRoo??????

[fever]

do not trade roughy

[brownmans muffins]

having a good look at Robertson.

will get games pumped into him and has a good bye.

more importantly is good w the CPs and attended a lot of centre bounces.

[Hagebear]

Definitely Robbo over Gray. Leppa loves him.

[nick wilkesmann]

yep, robertson.

do not trade roughy

+1
Roughy to Nroo would be trading a premium at bottom price to one at top price (aim to do the opposite). Hawks have had a pretty tough opening draw compared to saints easy one.

[Mark]

Keep Roughy....

Trade Hale to Nroo

[Slashers]

Definitely Robbo over Gray. Leppa loves him.

Does Leppa love Aish & Taylor too?

[Footyrulz]

Why would u trade Hale or Roughy?

Surely u didn't expect Hale to average more than about 80 if u got him? What has changed this?

Roughy was always going to be inconsistent but is a premium and will improve.

I would prioritise trading either May or your mid rookies.

[Ringo]

Beams is probably 2 weeks away and that may push Robbo out. Hopefully he comes back via the NEAFL as 3 weeks would take Robbo to Brisbane's byes. Just adding to the discussion for you.
Also worth noting that Moloney was uses as the sub this week and he is an inside player similar to Robbo.

In saying all this I will be trading in Robbo for one of my rookies but waiting for teams to be announced but just advising a few things you may want to consider.

[HotTiges]

where's Judd Magic.. he loves Roughy!!

[Judd Magic]

where's Judd Magic.. he loves Roughy!!

Here I am.

Oh the irony. LOL!  ::)