MRP from first 8 Matches Round 5

[Capper]

The demerit points are the 93.75 "points" he is awarded for each incident tabsy.

oh yeah, didnt read the fine print.

I hate that they can get a 25% discount with an early guilty plea, it doesnt woek on a murder charge

[Toga]

Woulda thought Hodgey might come under a bit of scrutiny for his jab on Stevie.

[Capper]

Seriously don't understand how Fyfe gets 2 weeks... Then Merrett gets 2 for what he did, then Glassy gets offered 1 for putting Wingard in hospital...

http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/afl/eagles-skipper-darren-glass-faces-nervous-wait-over-heavy-bump-on-chad-wingard/story-fniv6fhh-1226890591210

Wow that doesnt look like body contact to me, very lucky Dazza, buy a lottery ticket and take the week off

[Capper]

Garry Lyon agrees

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2014-04-22/mrp-got-it-wrong

[Mailman the 2nd]

Yeah while I was a pretty clean advocate of the MRP between 2010-2012 area, what they're doing now is devoid of all common sense and continuity

[The_Captain]

Seriously don't understand how Fyfe gets 2 weeks... Then Merrett gets 2 for what he did, then Glassy gets offered 1 for putting Wingard in hospital...

http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/afl/eagles-skipper-darren-glass-faces-nervous-wait-over-heavy-bump-on-chad-wingard/story-fniv6fhh-1226890591210

Wow that doesnt look like body contact to me, very lucky Dazza, buy a lottery ticket and take the week off

Please tabs...... Did you actually look at the picture? All it is is Glasses hip making contact with Wingards side!

The week is fair. Shouldnt of done it, But its not like the guy has sprinted in to make head high contact whilst he is picking up the ball..

[Bill Manspeaker]

Woulda thought Hodgey might come under a bit of scrutiny for his jab on Stevie.

if it was Bakes he'd cop 15 weeks (or however long it was)

[Ricochet]

Seriously don't understand how Fyfe gets 2 weeks... Then Merrett gets 2 for what he did, then Glassy gets offered 1 for putting Wingard in hospital...

http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/afl/eagles-skipper-darren-glass-faces-nervous-wait-over-heavy-bump-on-chad-wingard/story-fniv6fhh-1226890591210

Wow that doesnt look like body contact to me, very lucky Dazza, buy a lottery ticket and take the week off

Please tabs...... Did you actually look at the picture? All it is is Glasses hip making contact with Wingards side!

The week is fair. Shouldnt of done it, But its not like the guy has sprinted in to make head high contact whilst he is picking up the ball..

lol come on mate. Even as a WCE supporter you have to know that is worth more than 1

[Capper]

Seriously don't understand how Fyfe gets 2 weeks... Then Merrett gets 2 for what he did, then Glassy gets offered 1 for putting Wingard in hospital...

http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/afl/eagles-skipper-darren-glass-faces-nervous-wait-over-heavy-bump-on-chad-wingard/story-fniv6fhh-1226890591210

Wow that doesnt look like body contact to me, very lucky Dazza, buy a lottery ticket and take the week off

Please tabs...... Did you actually look at the picture? All it is is Glasses hip making contact with Wingards side!

The week is fair. Shouldnt of done it, But its not like the guy has sprinted in to make head high contact whilst he is picking up the ball..

ok, body contact but low impact?? He put him in hospital after jumping in the air and taking his eyes off the ball

Also did they not review the Hawthorn v Cats game as nothing is mentioned from that game

[The_Captain]

Seriously don't understand how Fyfe gets 2 weeks... Then Merrett gets 2 for what he did, then Glassy gets offered 1 for putting Wingard in hospital...

http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/afl/eagles-skipper-darren-glass-faces-nervous-wait-over-heavy-bump-on-chad-wingard/story-fniv6fhh-1226890591210

Wow that doesnt look like body contact to me, very lucky Dazza, buy a lottery ticket and take the week off

Please tabs...... Did you actually look at the picture? All it is is Glasses hip making contact with Wingards side!

The week is fair. Shouldnt of done it, But its not like the guy has sprinted in to make head high contact whilst he is picking up the ball..

lol come on mate. Even as a WCE supporter you have to know that is worth more than 1

Watching in live pace. Glass attack contest with eyes on ball. At last minute he turns to protect himself when he realizes he cant make it to the ball.

Pretty hard to stop at those kind of speeds Rico. He didnt make head contact either.

[Capper]

Seriously don't understand how Fyfe gets 2 weeks... Then Merrett gets 2 for what he did, then Glassy gets offered 1 for putting Wingard in hospital...

http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/afl/eagles-skipper-darren-glass-faces-nervous-wait-over-heavy-bump-on-chad-wingard/story-fniv6fhh-1226890591210

Wow that doesnt look like body contact to me, very lucky Dazza, buy a lottery ticket and take the week off

Please tabs...... Did you actually look at the picture? All it is is Glasses hip making contact with Wingards side!

The week is fair. Shouldnt of done it, But its not like the guy has sprinted in to make head high contact whilst he is picking up the ball..

lol come on mate. Even as a WCE supporter you have to know that is worth more than 1

Watching in live pace. Glass attack contest with eyes on ball. At last minute he turns to protect himself when he realizes he cant make it to the ball.

Pretty hard to stop at those kind of speeds Rico. He didnt make head contact either.

Why would you jump in the air then??

[Mailman the 2nd]

Yeah you can tell that he intended to hit Wingard there, should've been more than 1 week for sure

[Ricochet]

Seriously don't understand how Fyfe gets 2 weeks... Then Merrett gets 2 for what he did, then Glassy gets offered 1 for putting Wingard in hospital...

http://www.perthnow.com.au/sport/afl/eagles-skipper-darren-glass-faces-nervous-wait-over-heavy-bump-on-chad-wingard/story-fniv6fhh-1226890591210

Wow that doesnt look like body contact to me, very lucky Dazza, buy a lottery ticket and take the week off

Please tabs...... Did you actually look at the picture? All it is is Glasses hip making contact with Wingards side!

The week is fair. Shouldnt of done it, But its not like the guy has sprinted in to make head high contact whilst he is picking up the ball..

lol come on mate. Even as a WCE supporter you have to know that is worth more than 1

Watching in live pace. Glass attack contest with eyes on ball. At last minute he turns to protect himself when he realizes he cant make it to the ball.

Pretty hard to stop at those kind of speeds Rico. He didnt make head contact either.

Disagree man. He took his eye off the ball and made a decision to clean up wingard rather than spoil. It wasn't a reaction as a protection measure either. He also leaves the ground which is a big no-no. It looks as though he does make contact with the head as well.

Have broken down below.

Eyes on the ball



Focus changes to Wingard



Leaves ground. Front on contact with upper body, possibly the head

[Capper]

that elbow looks mighty close to his face/head as well

[Bill Manspeaker]

yep well said Rico.

and apparently that deserves the same punishment as a little love tap to the guts  :o