Dom Tyson substitute - mistake?

[HotTiges]

Don't know what to make of this..

@Thomo_Grant: Roos substitutes MF Tyson & admits he made a mistake. Well done Roosy - now that didn't hurt did it. More of it.

[AlexIsOnFire]

Was very surprised Dyson was subbed, there were plenty of spuds out there for Melbourne yet Roos decides to sub one of his better midfielders.

I will hold Dyson, but it has almost halted any more price gains

[ClarksonsArmy]

I think roos would have been spewing in qtr 4 when they ran over the GC

He may have had a niggle the past 2 weeks which we may be unaware about and 85% fit

[JBs-Hawks]

I think roos would have been spewing in qtr 4 when they ran over the GC

He may have had a niggle the past 2 weeks which we may be unaware about and 85% fit

If he had a niggle dont think roos would have said it was a mistake subbing him.

[Ricochet]

That's interesting. Wonder who he is thinking he should have subbed in hindsight

[ClarksonsArmy]

A tall I'm assuming

[Capper]

Obviously the reverse buffalo theory.

Get rid of the better mid and the whole group goes worse rather than get rid of the worst and the group gets better

[Big Mac]

As bad as Spencer was I don't think we had anyone to take over in the ruck. He was probably thinking Jetta.

[batt]

Hmm.  The only thing which would make we want to toss him before the byes is his JS.  This admission from Roosy makes it a little more intriguing.

[HotTiges]

Possibly either Tyson or MThomas to go this week ..leaning to Thomas due to too many R8 bye players

[WizzFizz]

his be is 98 so if he gets a 100 hell stay the same with a lower be

even if he gets about 70 hell drop by 15-20k only

[Bully]

Still torn on Tyson, part of me thinks he'll bounce back strongly, he certainly has the talent.

[H1bb3i2d]

I think I'll hold him, personally. May drop a little this week, but he has a good 4 weeks until his bye and I think he can safely average 70odd over the next month, which should see him come back up. Hopefully Roosy sees the talent and just wanted to send him a little message that he won't accept mediocrity, and he'll bounce back strongly!

Ellis will miss a few, then drop a lot before rising again, and with his injury history I dont want to keep him long enough to find out.

Langdon is reaching his max. Dunstan is an interesting one - started he last couple of games well but just went missing. If he can put 4 quarters together and pump out another 100 then he's well back on track to get to $400k - the same boat as Tyson, however I see Tyson as a tad safer to keep.

So as far as trading out Tyson goes, he's down on my priority list to trade out.

[Ricochet]

Yeh I'm holding until round 10. Need him to play through the byes

[Fid]

The way I look at it is this, Tyson still has a BE of 98 and will more than likely drop in price whilst Ellis more than likely won't play and he can wait until next week.

Tyson to Robertson for me