Defence premo poll.

Started by benharris222, April 19, 2014, 06:37:03 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

benharris222

I can trade out jimmy Webster for any of these! Leaning towards Simpson, but Burgoyne is looking good!

nperera95

All great options there mate. Burgoyne would be a great POD and he is playing great footy! Simpson very consistent player for the blues and you can't go wrong with Hibberd either! All great options but I'm leaning towards Burgoyne just because not many people have him and therefore would be a great POD

benharris222

Quote from: nperera95 on April 19, 2014, 06:58:07 PM
All great options there mate. Burgoyne would be a great POD and he is playing great footy! Simpson very consistent player for the blues and you can't go wrong with Hibberd either! All great options but I'm leaning towards Burgoyne just because not many people have him and therefore would be a great POD

I'm with you mate, gunna go for him just for some difference. Shouldn't be too much difference between them all.

GoLions

Burgoyne is prone to those really showerty scores though. Last year had 10 scores under 80, with 6 of them being 65 or less.
Simpson had 8 scores under 80, with 4 of those coming in the first 4 rounds as he had a very slow start. Only 2 scores of 65 or less.
Hibberd only went under 80 4 times, with 1 score of 65 or less. Only 8 scores of 100+ though as opposed to Simpson's 12 (and Burgoyne only 6).

I'd probably take Hibberd or Simpson.

tigertops

Simpsons price is too good to pass up on I reckon. Should be a top 6 def and at this price bargain.

T Dog

Rhyce Shaw and Heater surely

HotTiges

Did you trade in the end? Webster actually played his best game for the club..still you wouldn't be too disappointed picking up Burgoyne etc..

benharris222

Quote from: HotTiges on April 20, 2014, 08:00:47 AM
Did you trade in the end? Webster actually played his best game for the club..still you wouldn't be too disappointed picking up Burgoyne etc..

Unfortunately I did trade and it backfired immediately. Was tossing up between dale Thomas and Xavier Ellis for crouch, traded Thomas and put Ellis on the field (hoping he would make enough money to trade to Ryan griffin next week. And Webster out for Burgoyne. Knowing my luck he'll get injured.

desired77

Quote from: benharris222 on April 20, 2014, 10:12:44 AM
Quote from: HotTiges on April 20, 2014, 08:00:47 AM
Did you trade in the end? Webster actually played his best game for the club..still you wouldn't be too disappointed picking up Burgoyne etc..

Unfortunately I did trade and it backfired immediately. Was tossing up between dale Thomas and Xavier Ellis for crouch, traded Thomas and put Ellis on the field (hoping he would make enough money to trade to Ryan griffin next week. And Webster out for Burgoyne. Knowing my luck he'll get injured.


thats why i keep him for this week mate because after scoring 30 there is only one way to go and that is up which he dida nd scored like 92 so im happy i went  Caddy to crouch and tyson to hibberd