Take currie's 51 or trade mumford?

Started by MC, April 19, 2014, 06:35:21 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

MC

Lots of people in this boat I'd say, what should we do?

Ps. 25 trades left, mainly going for leagues. Only got 1 score from mummy before he missed.

nperera95

Well personally i would keep him but it depends who you are playing against as well. Mummy will be back soon so i recommend that you hold for atleast another week mate

Ricochet

If your only going for League how is the rest of your matchup/team going?

Bully

If Mummy is out again and Currie gets dropped you will have to trade anyway. Daw kicked 5 in the ressies and GWS have stated Mummy is 3-4 weeks away. Chances are you'll have to trade next week.

MC

I thought GWS said 1-2 weeks but the AFL said 3-4... has that changed?

Bully

Quote from: MC on April 19, 2014, 07:36:29 PM
I thought GWS said 1-2 weeks but the AFL said 3-4... has that changed?

Apparently updated to 3-4 by GWS, maybe someone can confirm this but multiple sources have stated the same information.

Mailman the 2nd

Mumford usually has strange injuries that take an odd amount of time to heal (at least playing for Sydney)

I'd probably trade him, but unsure

enzedder

Quote from: Bully on April 19, 2014, 06:58:55 PM
If Mummy is out again and Currie gets dropped you will have to trade anyway. Daw kicked 5 in the ressies and GWS have stated Mummy is 3-4 weeks away. Chances are you'll have to trade next week.
Been playing on my mind all week. No further news coming out of GWS. Considering he may miss next week and Currie could get dropped I think I'm going to pull the trigger and trade him now. Doc Larkins seems to think it may stretch out and Mummy has had the odd injuries in the past. Whilst I'd love to save the trade the smart thing seems to be dump him.
Gutted I didn't even get a game out of him. A complete waste of a trade.
Currie's 51 as cover is what you'd expect and the decision to go to Minson isn't too hard considering that score.
Some of my league games look like being close and this could ensure I get over the line too. Providing Minson scores 52 I'm up in the rankings too.
Talking myself into it.

jeesh

Quote from: Bully on April 19, 2014, 06:58:55 PM
If Mummy is out again and Currie gets dropped you will have to trade anyway. Daw kicked 5 in the ressies and GWS have stated Mummy is 3-4 weeks away. Chances are you'll have to trade next week.

I'm gonna go out on a limb and say Petrie will get dropped for Daw. Just wishful thinking but Petrie has been pretty ordinary so far.

RaisyDaisy

Quote from: jeesh on April 20, 2014, 04:27:42 AM
I'm gonna go out on a limb and say Petrie will get dropped for Daw. Just wishful thinking but Petrie has been pretty ordinary so far.

I cant remember the last time a captain got dropped. Cant see it happening. Currie will be out, just hasn't done enough

nostradamus

It depends whether you're going for winning your league or getting the highest overall ranking (while still trying to win your league too of course)

League .........keep
Overall ..........trade

jeesh

He's the captain? I seriously didn't know that. Ok then he will remain in the team hahahahah!

RaisyDaisy

Quote from: jeesh on April 20, 2014, 04:39:26 AM
He's the captain? I seriously didn't know that. Ok then he will remain in the team hahahahah!

Hehehe I'm pretty sure his the captain while Swallow is out

fever


Keeper27

holding on to him. taking Curries 51.