Aish

[Donnie Brasco]

Would you field him over any of these blokes this week...

Dunstan
Tyson
Ellis

Thanks in advance guys!

[vmac66]

Dunstan , Tyson , aish , Ellis . .

[Bones Bombers]

Dunstan , Tyson , aish , Ellis . .

[Donnie Brasco]

Cheers lads, much apprecited.

I've got Crouch on my bench as well, does that change anything?

[vmac66]

Crouch or Ellis last . .

[Donnie Brasco]

Thought so, thanks again mate.

[Judd Magic]

Wouldn't go with what anyone has said mate.

I'd go with Crouch as he is playing GWS and Ellis as West Coast will get a few players back this week and will be back playing in Perth.

Dunstan will hardly get any of the ball just like last week due to Essendons high possession game.

[Donnie Brasco]

So Juddy, you reckon Dunstan and Aish should sit on the pine?

[colmullet]

yeah its a toughie still of who to field, got to pick 4 out of Tyson, Polec, Dunstan, Ellis, Crouch and Aish

Thinking Tyson and Polec are still locks

Could throw a blanket over the other 4 though

Maybe discount Aish, he hasn't put up a 75+ score yet where others have....however with an undermanned Brisbane midfield and Richmond's also a bit undermanned he could get a fair run in the guts

[Donnie Brasco]

I absolutely agree Mullet Magic, Tyson and Polec are kinda-almost, first picked, but as for the others...

[Judd Magic]

So Juddy, you reckon Dunstan and Aish should sit on the pine?

Yeah I'd put Dunstan and Aish on the pine for sure mate.

[Judd Magic]

I absolutely agree Mullet Magic, Tyson and Polec are kinda-almost, first picked, but as for the others...

Yeah Polec and Tyson locks to start.

I agree that its hard to pick two out of guys like Dunstan, Aish, Crouch, Ellis, Kelly, etc.

Crouch for me seems a lock as he's a natural ball magnet so knows how to find his own ball. Also playing GWS should make things easier for him.

Ellis should score well over in Perth with all West Coasts in's I reckon. He is the more experienced player out of Dunstan too and his game wont be as lob sided compared to Dunstans where I think Essendon will smash the Saints.

[djbics]

Personally I'd be checking at the start of each game in order to see if any of them get the vest, not that any of them should but....
Tyson looked a little sore last week for Melbourne and has been doing a mountain of work for a player in what is essentially his first full season (and has a history with injuries, it wouldn't surprise me if Roos vested him one random week)
Crouch worries me a little, as he does seem more likely to be vested than the others, so I would probably rate him and Ellis as the lesser of the lot, though it's certainly a decent problem to have.....compare it to assesing rookies in other positions, especially the fwds!

[juzztheball]

Im going Polec, Aish and Dunstan on the field.

Aish is definitely not sub and Tyson had a quiet game last week... could possibly be sub candidate? I dunno, im probably gonna cop stick for that comment but oh well