Jarred McVeigh vs. Kade Simpson

[tg1810]

Cannot split the two. Is McVeigh getting the same midfield time as last year? Will the tag bother either of the two?

Who is better option to get into my team?

Justification would be great!

[AaronKirk]

Should aim to get both into your side by the end of the byes.

At this stage Simpson for mine. Round 9 bye is very enticing he has the ability to pump out 120+ scores as he did last weekend.

[Bully]

Check your bye structure and go with the guy who will give you a full squad over the 3 weeks. Both are must haves IMO.

[JonH3]

McVeigh easily! Proven performer, don't see the hype on Simpson at all.

[HotTiges]

McVeigh easily! Proven performer, don't see the hype on Simpson at all.

No worries mate..

[JonH3]

McVeigh easily! Proven performer, don't see the hype on Simpson at all.

No worries mate..

Diehard Swans supporter, sorry for bias. But is Simpson good enough to go past a 100+ average in McVeigh?

[GoLions]

McVeigh easily! Proven performer, don't see the hype on Simpson at all.

How is Simpson not proven? Going from 2009-2013, these are his respective averages; 93.9, 99.8, 94.5, 94.1, 95.1
And he's averaging 95 already this year, slightly more than McVeigh at 93.2
And he's 42.8k cheaper

Would want both in my side at the end of the season, but Simpson has probably bottomed out in price now, whereas McVeigh could probably get a bit lower, or at least stay around that price for a few weeks

[JonH3]

McVeigh easily! Proven performer, don't see the hype on Simpson at all.

How is Simpson not proven? Going from 2009-2013, these are his respective averages; 93.9, 99.8, 94.5, 94.1, 95.1
And he's averaging 95 already this year, slightly more than McVeigh at 93.2
And he's 42.8k cheaper

Would want both in my side at the end of the season, but Simpson has probably bottomed out in price now, whereas McVeigh could probably get a bit lower, or at least stay around that price for a few weeks

Never said he wasn't proven... I just said McVeigh is proven. But thank you, I now understand the hype.

[tbagrocks]

McVeigh easily! Proven performer, don't see the hype on Simpson at all.

No worries mate..

Diehard Swans supporter, sorry for bias. But is Simpson good enough to go past a 100+ average in McVeigh?

Ever even Simpson play? ??? I know McVeigh is like a good wine but dude