Chop titch or franklin?

[Belegur]

Traded in Franklin for Dahlhaus last week hoping he'd turned the corner and help my bye structure, also have T.mitchell now I have to fix this mess.

So I'm planning on bringing fasolo in which should I axe? Franklin seems the obvious choice but is also less likely to be dropped/sub. Also wondering what the effect of tippet coming back might be? Surely franklin can't play worse but it might help him?

[juzztheball]

No offense but of all the stupid trades that have been proposed I think your Dahlhaus to Franklin last week tops the lot  :o I think you clearly need to hold both, why youre evem considering moving buddy on after 1 week bamboozles me!

[GCSkiwi]

Surely you have bigger worries than two players who were a risk already? You traded in Buddy after 2 crap scores and 1 good score, now you're upset that he got a crap score again? And Titchell was always a risk of 2nd year blues but he's had 2 good scores and 2 bad scores so far, if you trade everyone who gives you a record like that you're gonna be out of trades before the byes...

[HotTiges]

Agree shouldn't be trading out these guys.. Surely there is something else that needs attending to.

[Belegur]

Negative the rest of my side is shredding, rookies havent peaked yet and I have crouch, dont have the ruck problems. Should of added im only interested in getting as high on overall as possible otherwise obviously would of held dahlhaus for a while and copped scores from the bench. In hindsight getting both these guys was a mistake and ive made a poor trade but I dont need help to know that. Just looking for opinions on who will preform best up till the round 10 bye, or reasons not to get fasolo? and +200k in the bank from this trade should allow me to go from ellis to Swan/Griffen/Thompson next week. Appreciate the feedback though, respect the hold trades advice.

[GCSkiwi]

If you're going for overall then I would make a call between the two of them, hold one and trade the other. But I don't envy you in making that decision, there's reasons to hold or trade both of them. Even if the rest of your team is fine now, you need to think conservatively in the sense of getting a complete team of premiums - you'll be spending trades later to cash in on your rookies, and then more after that because it's unlikely you'll manage a finished team in just one round of UG/DG all your current rookies.

[Ricochet]

Even if going for overall keep both mate. You'll need your trades through the byes and in Buddy's case he has had two poor scores from two wet games. He'll be ok, it was always going to be a roller coaster

[Belegur]

Thanks for the input i'll consider