Worth while cashing in on Dom tyson for crouch?

[desired77]

what are your thoughts

im thinking of doing this so that  i can trade caddy to fasolo also which will leave me with 360 upgrade webster next week and play fasolo as f6 thoughts

[kilbluff1985]

hi mate there are other threads around you could look at for help on this topic

i think you should hold Tyson until just before his round 10 bye then upgrade him i'm sure you have enough round 8 bye players don't need another one

[Marcos83]

Yeah a lot of discussion regarding this already. Tyson > crouch is a wasted trade. His averaging 90 +. Has a bit more money to make.

[HotTiges]

Upgrade Tyson,not downgrade.. Chop another cow

[shaker]

Upgrade Tyson,not downgrade.. Chop another cow

Agree must be upgraded so hang on for at least another couple of rounds unless you have some cash in the bank and you can afford a gun think he will be leaking cash before his round 10 bye

[GCSkiwi]

Upgrade Tyson,not downgrade.. Chop another cow

Upgrade Tyson,not downgrade.. Chop another cow

Agree must be upgraded so hang on for at least another couple of rounds unless you have some cash in the bank and you can afford a gun think he will be leaking cash before his round 10 bye

Not sure I understand what you guys mean? What's the difference? If you chop another cow (Let's say M.Thomas)  and used the cash to upgrade Tyson, that's the same result as if you downgraded Tyson and used the cash to upgrade Thomas...

ie Thomas > Crouch, Tyson > Jelwood is exactly the same as Tyson > Crouch, Thomas > Jelwood...

Tyson's 50 this week is a real spanner, if he'd scored higher then it's a no brainer to hold him, but the 50 decreases his price rise for a few rounds, even if he goes back to 90+. Who is going to be available as a downgrade in round 9/10 if you wait now? That's my concern, Crouch averaging 63 goes up to 250k by round 9, 130k above his price now. Tyson is not going to make 130k between now and then, just because of the 50...

[shaker]

Upgrade Tyson,not downgrade.. Chop another cow

Upgrade Tyson,not downgrade.. Chop another cow

Agree must be upgraded so hang on for at least another couple of rounds unless you have some cash in the bank and you can afford a gun think he will be leaking cash before his round 10 bye

Not sure I understand what you guys mean? What's the difference? If you chop another cow (Let's say M.Thomas)  and used the cash to upgrade Tyson, that's the same result as if you downgraded Tyson and used the cash to upgrade Thomas...

ie Thomas > Crouch, Tyson > Jelwood is exactly the same as Tyson > Crouch, Thomas > Jelwood...

Tyson's 50 this week is a real spanner, if he'd scored higher then it's a no brainer to hold him, but the 50 decreases his price rise for a few rounds, even if he goes back to 90+. Who is going to be available as a downgrade in round 9/10 if you wait now? That's my concern, Crouch averaging 63 goes up to 250k by round 9, 130k above his price now. Tyson is not going to make 130k between now and then, just because of the 50...

Sort of saying the same thing as you that these trades must result in getting a gun in Thomas > Crouch , Tyson > Selwood or the other way round is fine as long as he has the 90 - 100k in the bank to do it otherwise just wait a couple of weeks Tyson's B/E is only 38 he will still make some cash yet

[frogjumper]

Expect another 70-100k out of Tyson. Too early to offload.
Maybe look at your other rookie mids.
Ellis, Aish or Cunningham are the only 3 id consider downgrading at this point.
All other rookies still have too much cash to generate to downgrade

[Big Mac]

Not sure I understand what you guys mean? What's the difference? If you chop another cow (Let's say M.Thomas)  and used the cash to upgrade Tyson, that's the same result as if you downgraded Tyson and used the cash to upgrade Thomas...

ie Thomas > Crouch, Tyson > Jelwood is exactly the same as Tyson > Crouch, Thomas > Jelwood...

Tyson's 50 this week is a real spanner, if he'd scored higher then it's a no brainer to hold him, but the 50 decreases his price rise for a few rounds, even if he goes back to 90+. Who is going to be available as a downgrade in round 9/10 if you wait now? That's my concern, Crouch averaging 63 goes up to 250k by round 9, 130k above his price now. Tyson is not going to make 130k between now and then, just because of the 50...

I think they're talking about playing Tyson during round 8 and 9 and then upgrading him to a premium with the round 8/9 bye. His round 10 bye means keeping him will result in more points in the long term (effectively skip his bye) and will give potentially two extra weeks of cash generation over a round 8 bye rookie.

[desired77]

To All the people who told me to hold

Well i just pocketed 200k and got a 104 from a bloke that played 3 qtrs While tyson is at 22 atm nearly end of 2nd qtr

So talk about going with your guy feeling

It pays offf

[Bully]

To All the people who told me to hold

Well i just pocketed 200k and got a 104 from a bloke that played 3 qtrs While tyson is at 22 atm nearly end of 2nd qtr

So talk about going with your guy feeling

It pays offf

Thank god you did that, Tyson to hit the ton now.  ;)

[WizzFizz]

To All the people who told me to hold

Well i just pocketed 200k and got a 104 from a bloke that played 3 qtrs While tyson is at 22 atm nearly end of 2nd qtr

So talk about going with your guy feeling

It pays offf

Thank god you did that, Tyson to hit the ton now.  ;)

tyson has the r10 bye too, crouch is r8 :P

[Samsturmfels]

You would be happy with that trade, Tyson just got subbed out

[nas]

To All the people who told me to hold

Well i just pocketed 200k and got a 104 from a bloke that played 3 qtrs While tyson is at 22 atm nearly end of 2nd qtr

So talk about going with your guy feeling

It pays offf

Thank god you did that, Tyson to hit the ton now.  ;)
[/quote

Err Subbed off now

[LF]

So close to doing this today but weighed up trades left and thought he`d make his BE so didn`t do it