NicNat trading poll

[felsty]

So I'm sick of these poor scores, never picking an underdone player again thinking he has the capability to make top five in his possie
What to do what to do..
Is there much risk jumping on Lloyd a week early when Impey is projected to make maybe 11k?

[felsty]

Close poll, can anyone give me there reasoning as to why either way?

[Bully]

Close poll, can anyone give me there reasoning as to why either way?

Nic Nat was limping on the weekend, he's clearly not right at the moment. Best to cut your losses and bring in a form ruckman. Sauce has a terrific run coming up, I think he can maintain a 100 average, Impey may even be dropped soon with Monfries & Wingard to come back.

[redfield]

To be honest, unless you're in the hunt for overall then I'd stick fat.

[jeesh]

To be honest, unless you're in the hunt for overall then I'd stick fat.

I disagree with this. I'm not in the hunt for overall whatsoever but these rubbish scores from Nic Nat are costing me league games. If he doesn't play its time to trade

[felsty]

I'm just outside the top 5000 after 4 rounds so still think I'm in with some sort of chance.. I'm more focused on bettering my ranking every year than league games anyway

In terms of trading premos I haven't done so yet and believe this is the only one am looking to do. Think I just have to admit that it was wrong to start him and jump off. Sauce has had 3/4 games over 110+ and a good run coming up

[jeesh]

After the frustration and stress Nic Nat has caused us I think its time to get $h1t faced on the sauce! Just wish I could do it in one trade but Rohan is a spud and might as well go

[felsty]

I feel like it's time to cut the dead wood

[geoffmack]

I'm just outside the top 5000 after 4 rounds so still think I'm in with some sort of chance.. I'm more focused on bettering my ranking every year than league games anyway

In terms of trading premos I haven't done so yet and believe this is the only one am looking to do. Think I just have to admit that it was wrong to start him and jump off. Sauce has had 3/4 games over 110+ and a good run coming up

Agreed, Sauce for mine. GET HIM IN

[Keeper27]

He's bled too much cash. Keep him if you think he can turn it around.

[Gigantor]

I'm in the same boat, no longer trust him to bounce back in any meaningful way. Plus West Coast play GWS in Perth before their bye so high chance of being rested.
I'm going Caddy > Fasolo    NicNat > Sauce

[Big Mac]

Everyone still trading Nic Nat?

[Doggoneit]

yes I am trading him out - have to admit I made a mistake with him - and a 3 ruck strategy is not helping

I am downgrading Hanley to Suckers and upgrading NicNat to Cox/Minson

[Blues Blues Blues]

I'm trading. I can afford any ruck, but can't decide best pick?  :-[

Cox - getting old, scoring has been ordinary, BUT with Nic Nat playing like shower he may score better?
Goldy - his shoulder concerns me, plus the fact Currie potentially playing aside him could cost points
Minno - can he repeat last year?
Sauce - he flowered me over last year, and I haven't got over it

I know there is a mummy trade thread, but what are Nic Nat owners thinking?

[Marstar]

Got him for reason.  Not trusting any alternative in the short term.