POLL Currie v Derickx TRADE IN

[Luigi197]

I think it's being asked around, but not to too much prevail so far.

Currie or Derickx?
Who's likely to score more, and more consistently?
Who's more likely to keep their spot on the team?
How are they when they're not rucking?

Cheers :

EDIT: The reason this trade is happening is because I need cover for Mcevoy. And JKH is getting the flick.

[jeesh]

Derickx could be dropped as early as this week for Nankervis

[E-Lemon_ator]

If you dont have either now I prob wouldnt bother getitng them in.
I started with Currie, his score of 40 odd covered Mcevoy last week and will do the same this week. Will take anything over 40

However in saying that, I wouldnt get them in as cant see either playing many more games.

[Luigi197]

I probably should've mentioned the reason i'm getting them in is because i have Mcevoy out and need cover.. aha i'll edit that in the original post now.

[E-Lemon_ator]

Mate, Mcevoy will play next week, do you really want to burn a trade for 50 points that Currie may get?

[Luigi197]

Mate, Mcevoy will play next week, do you really want to burn a trade for 50 points that Currie may get?

But... otherwise i'm playing with 21? I don't see why i wouldn't want to trade to not only have that extra 50 points, but also make more money than if i didn't do the trade.

Current lines.
RUC: Sandi, Mcevoy (Thurlow, King)
FWD: ..... Taylor (Impey, JKH)

[Luigi197]

Also, i'd really like some more reasons why people are voting for Derickx over Currie?

[colmullet]

Currie for mine, cant see the sydney boys getting much of a run when Tippett comes back into the team

[E-Lemon_ator]

end of the day its your call but i think thats a crazy trade.  When you run out of trades later in the year please remember the time you traded in Currie.  Ull be kicking yourself
Trades are gold mate, Currie will never score well and cant see him playing many more games. He might just get to 200k if the kangas play him enough

[RaisyDaisy]

Currie for me. As others have mentioned, Dericx and Nank are fighting for a spot - a spot that I don't think will be around for long once Tippett comes back anyway

I think Lemon has a point as well. Your using a trade to avoid a donut, but that trade is going to most likely net you 50 points, and probably wont make a great deal of money too.

If you want to burn a trade to avoid a donut, Id rather punt McEvoy and get Mummy or Cox

[tor01doc]

McEvoy to Mummy?

[jumbo]

I'm in the same boat.. got mcevoy and Sandi and same king thurlow bench. Worried about copping a donut again. But am just after league wins... I have enough cash to go to mummy. Should I pull the trigger and get mummy, or hold out one more week and save a trade???

[Luigi197]

i don't want to sideways trade a premium to avoid a donut. and i kinda don't wanna jump on the mummy train.

is it really that bad of an idea to trade JKH to Currie?
this way i also have cover for future late outs.

[tor01doc]

Mummy.

[RaisyDaisy]

JKH to Currie is fine. It's just the same as trading JKH to any other rookie, and you need a R3 that plays