Nic Naitanui?

[MatthewDoubrava]

i have enough coin in the bank to trade him to anyone, im thinking mumford before he sky rockets to over 600k.

anyone else in mind?

[muzza3465]

Waste of a trade mate nic nat will come good he has been eased into the season because of no nab cup games its a matter of time for him to go bang maybe even this week hes had a couple of runs now

[MatthewDoubrava]

if i save the trade i will be left with 239k, which is obviously a win for coming weeks. but i feel nic nat has not yet fully recovered from his injury, and i dont think he quite will this year, but i think im going to take your advice and see how he goes in the next few weeks, saving a trade is always a good thing :) thanks mate

[makita]

yea stick with him. u knew he was underdone when u chose him so just wear a few bad scores and wait for him to go bang. The

first sign of him stepping out of neutral would be Sinclairs omission. Fingers crossed for 6:25pm tonight!

[MatthewDoubrava]

yeah, hoping he does go bang soon, thnaks for your help

[Keeper27]

how long will people wait?? another 3 weeks??

[roti]

how long will people wait?? another 3 weeks??

Already out of the race for overall so i've got another 15 weeks or so before league finals start ahaah

[MatthewDoubrava]

So do i trade or Keep??!! (Nic Nat)

[Keeper27]

personally i'd get him out. i was in the same situation with Leuey.
i expected 100's but with West in the team it made his scores suffer.
got him out, no point in having a player who'll bleed money and not getting you points.

sure i reckon Nic nat will come back, but how long will you wait??
lets say you hold onto him. lets say it takes another 2-3weeks before he picks up again.
thats 4 price drops, and less points that you chose to stick with just so you can have a "FIT" NicNat later on.

[MatthewDoubrava]

yeah that seems like a fair point, but who to go for him, Mummy? if i get mumford in i will still have 150 odd k in the bank? worth it??

[GCSkiwi]

how long will people wait?? another 3 weeks??

I guess the problem with that logic is it comes from a mind that wouldn't have picked him to begin with... It was the same for me with all the people talking about trading Ryder - my immediate reaction is "of course you should trade him, because you should never have started with him". But if you were mentally ill enough to start him then you can't claim divine intervention has cured you after a few games. So I agree with the people saying that if you started with him you couldn't have expected him to smash it from game one. Thus you should hold onto him now. I agree, I wouldn't have started with him so think it's funny that people are complaining about him now, but that's what they bought into...

NicNat will either be back with a vengeance, or will be a spud who totally vindicates my "get on the Cox" campaign. Mr. Doubrava, you have to decide which one of those you think he will be, and hold or trade accordingly. But surely you must have know you would be in for a bumpy start when you picked him?

[MatthewDoubrava]

i got nic nat in thinking not many people will be on him becasue of his injury, but i was hoping for scores of at least 80 or so. i wasnt expecting the big tonn every week. but i think im going to hold on to him for a few more weeks and see how he goes. i dont want to be waisting a stupid trade on him. and on the up side i save 250k

[Keeper27]

surely you must have know you would be in for a bumpy start when you picked him?

i get what you're saying. of course they had to expect a slow start with an interrupted preseason.
my situation with Leuey was different, had an OK preseason, just didnt realize the massive affect West would be on Leuey.

[GCSkiwi]

surely you must have know you would be in for a bumpy start when you picked him?

i get what you're saying. of course they had to expect a slow start with an interrupted preseason.
my situation with Leuey was different, had an OK preseason, just didnt realize the massive affect West would be on Leuey.

Yeah Leuey I can understand more. NicNat and Ryder...  :o

[Keeper27]

surely you must have know you would be in for a bumpy start when you picked him?

i get what you're saying. of course they had to expect a slow start with an interrupted preseason.
my situation with Leuey was different, had an OK preseason, just didnt realize the massive affect West would be on Leuey.

Yeah Leuey I can understand more. NicNat and Ryder...  :o

yeah, thats why i stayed away.