Kelly or KK?

[Johnahawk]

Trading Michie if he isn't named this week, who should I bring in? Kelly, or move Langdon / McDonald to the mids and get KK?

[RaisyDaisy]

Thinking the same myself, and I am going with Kelly as he seems to be a much better scorer than KK at this stage

[Daniel123]

Firstly a) where has this love for Kelly come from and
B) is he going to get a game?

[LF]

Firstly a) where has this love for Kelly come from and
B) is he going to get a game?

um he has played 2 games already one green vested
And has score very well indeed and he also looks very good

[Johnahawk]

Bit surprised, 10 to 1 in favour of Kelly so far! Was leaning towards KK originally, averaging almost 22 touches a game so should improve his scoring, and gives DPP link between Langdon & McDonald.

[Judd Magic]

Bit surprised, 10 to 1 in favour of Kelly so far! Was leaning towards KK originally, averaging almost 22 touches a game so should improve his scoring, and gives DPP link between Langdon & McDonald.

Um, KK isn't DPP.  ::)

[Cambo]

Bit surprised, 10 to 1 in favour of Kelly so far! Was leaning towards KK originally, averaging almost 22 touches a game so should improve his scoring, and gives DPP link between Langdon & McDonald.

Um, KK isn't DPP.  ::)

Um, yea but, no but....
Langdon or McDonald to the mids gives DPP link between them, not KK  :o

[_wato]

Firstly a) where has this love for Kelly come from and
B) is he going to get a game?

um he has played 2 games already one green vested
And has score very well indeed and he also looks very good

Kelly not a top 2 pick for nothing bud, is obviously a gun.. Gone under the radar as he went to GWS but he's better then the other few high profile picks such as Aish/Scharenberg/Billings etc

[Marcos83]

Both are very highly rated and will play alot of games. KK finished weak but I think he had about 9 touches in first quarter. His quality though and uses the ball well. Ignored GAJ a couple of times when every1 else wouldn't have.

Kelly mind you looks the goods as well and plays in the guts and as a result has more potential to get the ball and score well.

[woofy]

Bit surprised, 10 to 1 in favour of Kelly so far! Was leaning towards KK originally, averaging almost 22 touches a game so should improve his scoring, and gives DPP link between Langdon & McDonald.

Um, KK isn't DPP.  ::)

What he meant was if he traded in KK he would have a DPP link between Def/Mid (Langdon/McDonald)

I would still go for Kelly johnahawk.

[Ricochet]

Michie broke his jaw in the VFL on the wkend so he has to go. I would def look at Kelly over KK

[Woppa15]

I woul expect Kelly to be more consistent than KK.