Good Idea or Bad Idea?

[BigMac_93]

Thinking of going Langford/Georgiou to M Crouch (via Langdon DPP) which will enable me to go Leuey to Mumford. I know Mumford won't maintain his average but should still be a top 2-3 ruck at season end and I want Leuey out of my side. I held onto Jacobs for too long last year, not doing it again.

I know this goes against the rule to wait 2 weeks before getting a rookie but the Crows have lots of injuries and Crouch looked good after coming on in 2nd quarter.

Thoughts?

[E-Lemon_ator]

You said it yourself, its silly to make thjat trade this week because:
Langdon & Giorgio will make more $$ is they play this week whereas Crouch will not.
Have another look at Crouch next week to see if he can back it up.
Crouch played well over 1/2 the game and only scored 40 odd points.  Langford/Giorgiou8 are scoring that anyway.

Leave it one more week - youll make more $$ with yuor other 2 rookies, look at how crouch goes and then reassess

[GCSkiwi]

I agree with lemon about the rookies but if you're going to pull the trigger on Leuey to Mummy you need to do it this week. Having said that there are other options of rucks, Sauce has had an ok start though I wouldn't trust him after last year either. Otherwise NicNat could be pretty cheap soon at the rate he's going...

[tor01doc]

If you want your Mummy, then this week is your best option - or wait until he drops back a bit (he will, it's just a matter of by how much and when).

[dmac07]

I agree with lemon about the rookies but if you're going to pull the trigger on Leuey to Mummy you need to do it this week. Having said that there are other options of rucks, Sauce has had an ok start though I wouldn't trust him after last year either. Otherwise NicNat could be pretty cheap soon at the rate he's going...

Havent looked at the numbers, but check the breakevens to see how much Langord/Georgio are likely to increase compared to Mummy, with both their increases may cost you only the came coin to do this next week and you get an extra week to see Crouch. Havent done the numbers so this might not work but just a thought to run with.

[felsty]

Am I crazy for wanting to go NicNat > Mummy and Enright > Swallow?

[kilbluff1985]

You said it yourself, its silly to make thjat trade this week because:
Langdon & Giorgio will make more $$ is they play this week whereas Crouch will not.
Have another look at Crouch next week to see if he can back it up.
Crouch played well over 1/2 the game and only scored 40 odd points.  Langford/Giorgiou8 are scoring that anyway.

Leave it one more week - youll make more $$ with yuor other 2 rookies, look at how crouch goes and then reassess

bit harsh on Crouch he still got 18 touches and 4 tackles in that time he scored 45 points because Swans dominated most of the game which is even more positive that he still got 18 touches

i'm not saying bring him in this week but watch him closely this week hope he plays a full game

[GCSkiwi]

I agree with lemon about the rookies but if you're going to pull the trigger on Leuey to Mummy you need to do it this week. Having said that there are other options of rucks, Sauce has had an ok start though I wouldn't trust him after last year either. Otherwise NicNat could be pretty cheap soon at the rate he's going...

Havent looked at the numbers, but check the breakevens to see how much Langord/Georgio are likely to increase compared to Mummy, with both their increases may cost you only the came coin to do this next week and you get an extra week to see Crouch. Havent done the numbers so this might not work but just a thought to run with.

According to SC gold:
Mumford BE -8, projected to score 128 (I doubt, expect less, but ok), will increase $60.9k if he does
Langford Be -1, projected to score 40 (again I doubt, expect more), will increase $18.2k if he does
Georgious BE -26, projected to score 58, will go up $37.8k if he does

Numbers would suggest Langford out for Mummy would be a win

[Bully]

You said it yourself, its silly to make thjat trade this week because:
Langdon & Giorgio will make more $$ is they play this week whereas Crouch will not.
Have another look at Crouch next week to see if he can back it up.
Crouch played well over 1/2 the game and only scored 40 odd points.  Langford/Giorgiou8 are scoring that anyway.

Leave it one more week - youll make more $$ with yuor other 2 rookies, look at how crouch goes and then reassess

bit harsh on Crouch he still got 18 touches and 4 tackles in that time he scored 45 points because Swans dominated most of the game which is even more positive that he still got 18 touches

i'm not saying bring him in this week but watch him closely this week hope he plays a full game

Precisely, 51% TOG, he will be one of the best cash cows this year.