Swanny - Hold or Dump?

[C Judd 3 Votes]

I have Swanny in the mids. I can trade him to Jelwood or Watson or Stevie J.

Do people think I should give him another week?

I've already gone Michie to Tyson.
If i leave Swan for a week, I can go Rohan to Ambrose or Clurey to Griffiths / Langford.

What say you?

I'll kick myself if Swan pumps out a 150 this week. But will hate another 65 or something.

[GM]

In SC mate Swan to Jelwood for me.

[C Judd 3 Votes]

I dunno, what are the odds of him being a pig this week and tonning up?

Don't want to burn trades getting him out and then back in, like in 3 weeks  :o

[GoLions]

Keep him, waste of a trade if you get rid of him as you'll likely want him back later in the year

[AaronKirk]

Going against my rules about premos but I'd trade him to Jelwood now. If Swan regathers his fitness and form than bring him in after the round 8 bye. The way Bucks is using Swan to me would be a massive concern about his scores.

[n186]

I Also have Swan not sure what to do like i know his form isnt great but i do expect him to bounce back, but he will drop in price i am thinking either J selwood or get Tyson and gain $400k+ for further upgrades...

[lukebomber]

Going against my rules about premos but I'd trade him to Jelwood now. If Swan regathers his fitness and form than bring him in after the round 8 bye. The way Bucks is using Swan to me would be a massive concern about his scores.

+1
i can see Selwood averaging 5-10 more ppg then swan which would be worth a trade imo

[C Judd 3 Votes]

I think I'm going to keep him and bring Langford in for Clurey.

He is a premo. He will be a fallen premo if he is still stinking it up in 2 weeks. Then he will be gone, and I will be furious at keeping him lol.

But I'm not convinced a slow start to the season is the end for the PIG. Unless someone else can convince me!

[GM]

Keep him, waste of a trade if you get rid of him as you'll likely want him back later in the year

Not a cert in SC mate.

[GoLions]

Keep him, waste of a trade if you get rid of him as you'll likely want him back later in the year

Not a cert in SC mate.

Swan's SC average in the last 5 years;

2009 - 123.2
2010 - 126.8
2011 - 121.9
2012 - 126.3
2013 - 117.5

Yes he had a drop off last year, but did a similar thing in 2011 as well.

[C Judd 3 Votes]

They're pretty good averages. This week is do or die though.

[GM]

Keep him, waste of a trade if you get rid of him as you'll likely want him back later in the year

Not a cert in SC mate.

Swan's SC average in the last 5 years;

2009 - 123.2
2010 - 126.8
2011 - 121.9
2012 - 126.3
2013 - 117.5

Yes he had a drop off last year, but did a similar thing in 2011 as well.

And had him every year

[gunnerzzz]

Who knows, anything could happen. I'm gunna back him in tho!