Is this a crazy trade idea?

[Maggie May]

With news of Sinclair being injured for the pies, which will improve Bennedy's chances of getting a game, given his performance in the VFL (though the vest is still possible) I'm thinking this week:

Hodge to either Hibberd or Swallow for D3 (I'm thinking Swallow, given defenders are a bit up and down (all of them have been so far) anyway and Swallow gives me extra cash) and benching Mitchell.

Then go Rohan to Ambrose for F7.

This would leave me with $186k (assuming I go the Swallow route) to sort out Guthrie & Bennedy next week. We know Bennedy's price will hold next week due to not playing this week, and Guthrie has a break-even of 54 so he should just about hit that. The 186k would leave my options open if I need to replace one or both, though one of Ambrose or Taylor would need to play onfield if Bennedy doesn't play or gets the vest.

Does this sound like to crazy an idea?

[kilbluff1985]

ambrose might lose his spot when Belly is back

[cotch9]

isn't paddy ryder going to be out for a few weeks with his ankle injury

[kilbluff1985]

isn't paddy ryder going to be out for a few weeks with his ankle injury

Thurlow will play for him though

was confirmed Belly is on the LTI list so they can promote Thurlow also