Is Dom Tyson a must have?!?

[juzztheball]

So i made the rookie error of trading him out 5 minutes before the brisbane game for Aish. Held onto Michie instead. Naturally, seeing Tyson tear it up made me furious!

Question is, is he a must have? Or can Michie/Aish turn it around?

Thoughts?

Would have to downgrade a Webster/MacDonald to Laidler/Langford to afford this...

[tor01doc]

Not worth blowing a trade for him now.

He may end up being a keeper but unlikely.

If he consistently outscores Aish / Michie, then you lose a bit of cash and will just have to suck it up Princess - like I will be!  :(

[H1bb3i2d]

Yes. No doubt he will be around the 110 mark all year, making him a top 15 MID and possible M8 keeper all year, a steal for only $200oddk!!

[H1bb3i2d]

But srs, yeah he'll average a bit more than the other rooks, but is priced a bit more too, thus he will probably make around the same, and even if he earns a little more it wouldn't be worth the trade to bring him in

[vtaced]

In short yes. one of the best cash cows this year in my opinion. Also has excellent job security

[H1bb3i2d]

In short yes. one of the best cash cows this year in my opinion. Also has excellent job security

>Averages 90
>Hits 500k
>Makes 300k
>Pretty good return, agreed?

To be worth a trade, you'd want to make an extra $150-200k by doing so, so unless you have a rookie that's scoring below 60 (which gets to ~300-350k), the trade won't net you enough IMO.

We can't have every single player that we missed. The strategy is to find how much we can actually gain from them, but if your current option is doing alright themselves, the trade 'generally' isn't worth it.

[fever]

hibberd nailed it

[GCSkiwi]

But srs, yeah he'll average a bit more than the other rooks, but is priced a bit more too, thus he will probably make around the same, and even if he earns a little more it wouldn't be worth the trade to bring him in

This. If you have to make 2 trades just to bring him in there is no point. If you could get him in with 1 trade it might be worth considering but even then, I think if you missed the boat then

suck it up Princess

[tor01doc]

Excuse me while I go and suck it up.  :o

Missed him to fit Libber in!!

[Bill Manspeaker]

Excuse me while I go and suck it up.  :o

Missed him to fit Libber in!!

BOW DOWN, BOW DOWN, 1 2 3, SUCK IT UP

[Marcos83]

In short yes. one of the best cash cows this year in my opinion. Also has excellent job security

>Averages 90
>Hits 500k
>Makes 300k
>Pretty good return, agreed?

To be worth a trade, you'd want to make an extra $150-200k by doing so, so unless you have a rookie that's scoring below 60 (which gets to ~300-350k), the trade won't net you enough IMO.

We can't have every single player that we missed. The strategy is to find how much we can actually gain from them, but if your current option is doing alright themselves, the trade 'generally' isn't worth it.

If he averages 90 he will go to 450 k max. To get to 500k he needs an average of 100 I'm pretty sure. Correct me if I am wrong.

[Anubis]

No, he isn't/

[H1bb3i2d]

In short yes. one of the best cash cows this year in my opinion. Also has excellent job security

>Averages 90
>Hits 500k
>Makes 300k
>Pretty good return, agreed?

To be worth a trade, you'd want to make an extra $150-200k by doing so, so unless you have a rookie that's scoring below 60 (which gets to ~300-350k), the trade won't net you enough IMO.

We can't have every single player that we missed. The strategy is to find how much we can actually gain from them, but if your current option is doing alright themselves, the trade 'generally' isn't worth it.

If he averages 90 he will go to 450 k max. To get to 500k he needs an average of 100 I'm pretty sure. Correct me if I am wrong.

Somwhere in between,  depends if he can pull out a couple of good games in a row at a good time. I was being pretty generous so no one went "well I think he'll make more than that, so your point is invalid"

[Spuds11]

Has great job security at Melbourne looks a good player  if your heart is telling you to trade him in trade him in and put your mind at ease but remember that prices will not change until the completion of round 3 so you have another week to asses the situation

[Colty]

In short yes. one of the best cash cows this year in my opinion. Also has excellent job security

>Averages 90
>Hits 500k
>Makes 300k
>Pretty good return, agreed?

To be worth a trade, you'd want to make an extra $150-200k by doing so, so unless you have a rookie that's scoring below 60 (which gets to ~300-350k), the trade won't net you enough IMO.

We can't have every single player that we missed. The strategy is to find how much we can actually gain from them, but if your current option is doing alright themselves, the trade 'generally' isn't worth it.

If he averages 90 he will go to 450 k max. To get to 500k he needs an average of 100 I'm pretty sure. Correct me if I am wrong.

Somwhere in between,  depends if he can pull out a couple of good games in a row at a good time. I was being pretty generous so no one went "well I think he'll make more than that, so your point is invalid"

I think your better off trading for Macrae making 200k and getting big points while he makes you good cash.