Too Early to Trade 2 players out?

Started by adelaide13, March 24, 2014, 12:17:05 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

adelaide13

Is it too early to trade Daisy out for Watson and Cloke out for Hunter or Merrett?

Ricochet

What were your reasons for picking them?
Back your research and judgement, it's only one game :)

Dudge

This is not a shot at you Rico, really respect your posts. The thing is, when almost every reply is  " you picked them for a reason " from multiple, or should I say, every single person replying is the same, it sort of irks me.
. What if some one feels that they would prefer gun A instead of gun B, do they wait till their 400 points behind, "because they picked them for a reason " or do they get who they wan't? As I said , believe me, this is not directed to you Rico, but to people who reply about my rant above lol. Agree, coaches can't blow trades or expect their gun to score 130 1st game, but the " u picked them 4 a reason " is well and fine for fantasy addicts, but for newcomers, they probably think their fools for asking. And if they are fools, they'll learn in time

SydneyRox

Quote from: adelaide13 on March 24, 2014, 12:17:05 PM
Is it too early to trade Daisy out for Watson and Cloke out for Hunter or Merrett?

my gut says yes it is too early. take a breath and see how everyone goes in rnd2 and if they get named rnd3.

daisy is and always was a risk. it was his first game back in a long time, expecting him to score 100+ was maybe too much.

watson is a gun and this is a big upgrade.

cloke was always a MASSIVE risk,he goes missing too mych and cops plenty of attenrion, i would never have selected him.


Mr.Craig

I don't think things are going to get better for Cloke in the next couple of weeks. His last few games vs Sydney have been average and against Geelong he is 69.4 in the last 5. :-\

Nicko06

I think for a trade like daisy to Watson it's well worth it I'm personally bringing Watson in.
I also believe in getting your rookies right early instead of rushing in rounds 2-3..