Brodie Martin

[Griffo1982]

With Crouch not being named what do people think about swapping McDonald to M10 & picking Brodie Martin @ $175k as M6 seeing he is named at HB?
Are there any Crows supporters out there that could lend their opinion?

[4820]

Good question, I'm keen to hear from anyone with knowledge on this topic. 
Opinion on Martin, JS etc !

[GoLions]

If you had that much cash leftover to bring in Martin, I'd just prefer to upgrade Crouch to one of Aish, Sheed, Michie, Ellis (whoever you don't already have)

[Griffo1982]

If you had that much cash leftover to bring in Martin, I'd just prefer to upgrade Crouch to one of Aish, Sheed, Michie, Ellis (whoever you don't already have)

So you think Aish & Sheed are better options if named?

[Jimmykidd]

martin v webster?

[GoLions]

If you had that much cash leftover to bring in Martin, I'd just prefer to upgrade Crouch to one of Aish, Sheed, Michie, Ellis (whoever you don't already have)

So you think Aish & Sheed are better options if named?

My preference would be Aish, I have him myself.

[Marcos83]

A lot of talk about Martin at the moment. I downgraded him from Webster and upgraded Crouch to Aish.

Martins stocks will definitely rise and will probably go higher than Webster I reckon.

[RaisyDaisy]

His NAB numbers were very good - how is his JS? Would anyone pick him over McDonald?

[Marcos83]

Could someone please post his NAB numbers just to re confirm my confidence in him over webster.

[AaronKirk]

His NAB numbers were very good - how is his JS? Would anyone pick him over McDonald?

Brent Reilly would come back at some stage wouldn't he? Douglas recovering better than expected as well. Don't have either but would pick McDonald before Martin at this stage.

[RaisyDaisy]

73% game time, played all 3 games for scores of 75 49 105 at a rate of 95 points per 100 minutes

Who comes back soon that takes his spot?

[RaisyDaisy]

Hmmmmm his 25 years old now and over the past 5 years has played 2,2,5,7,2 games per year - not really encouraging

[AaronKirk]

Courtesy of Rico on the Adelaide FF board.

http://www.afc.com.au/news/2014-03-18/return-on-radar

Brent Reilly hoping to come back in round 2. I am presuming Reilly will play that sweeping role across half back

[Mr.Craig]

73% game time, played all 3 games for scores of 75 49 105 at a rate of 95 points per 100 minutes

Who comes back soon that takes his spot?

Maybe he will finally be able to cement a spot but I'd still be cautious. He has a habit of playing games early then disappearing, either through omission or injury.

2011 - Played Rounds 3-6, then didn't play again until Round 23
2012 - Played Rounds 3-4 then didn't play again until Round 12
2013 - Played Round 1 then didn't play again until Round 10

[SydneyRox]

Yeah, i think you need to be careful. He has been round for a while, injury and consitency are his main issuses, but he is talented. Big risk, Macdonald miles in front as a def, so I would go with GL suggestion and use the cash to upgrade to Aish