Tyson v Aish

[bwsh]

216k tyson... could he pssibly go to 400?
Aish 187K pocket cash and could also go to 350-400
thoughts

[Jroo]

Tyson for me, he's been in the AFL system for longer and Aish is more likely to start as the sub, IMO.

[AaronKirk]

Tyson is in his third year in the AFL system whilst Aish in in his first season. Tyson for me.

[Keeper27]

Tyson. No contest

[SydneyRox]

Tyson for me, he's been in the AFL system for longer and Aish is more likely to start as the sub, IMO.

Exactly Aish is good, but there is still some good talent in the mids at Brisbane. Same cant be said for the Dees, Tyson will go straight into the midfield rotation and could end up in the top3 of their mids by season end

[Anubis]

Leppa has said he'll play Aish as much as he can. He's all class.

[Bully]

Aish is still a predominantly outside player, he will be relying on big disposal numbers to compete with Tyson. There's also the question of a first year body competing with a third year one. Also check out their respective draws, Brisbane has a tough run whereas Melbourne play most of the cellar dwellers in the early stages.

[Ringo]

Both imo will end up around the $400k so can not go wrong with either pick.  Biased but I would go with Aish as he is cheaper and with the injury to Beams he will get games and not be the sub. Agree he is an outside player but so is Mayes and we know how he scored last year.

[Keeper27]

so Tyson is a lock.
question is Aish or Michie??

similarly priced (+15K) both should be decent cash cows... or another of my rookies?? Ellis/Dunstan??