Rockliff or Libba?

[Elcapitano]

Quick thoughts on how you think each of these guys will score for the year?
Will Rockliff be affected by a tag more than Libba?

Who will average more for the season?

[Hippo]

Quick thoughts on how you think each of these guys will score for the year?
Will Rockliff be affected by a tag more than Libba?

Who will average more for the season?

Hows anyone meant to answer that question?

don't have the answer so have taken both

pick the player you enjoy watching more, you can't go wrong either way

[GoLions]

I highly doubt Rocky will suffer from the tag, seeing as Rich and Hanley would both be tagged before him.

I've taken Rocky so far, but Libba is very tempting. The fact that Rocky averaged like 128 in the last 2 months because he was played as a midfielder gets him over the line for me.

[Ringo]

With doubts on Griffen playing Libba now the obvious one for tag - So based on that Rocky.

[_wato]

Why is Libba the obvious one to tag? I agree he may get a run with but would he get a hard tag? That would be left to your more outside players as they will get affected more.. So your Cooney, Boyd, Dahlhaus, and even Macrae etc while Griffen's out.

Even then I don't think a tag will effect him because of his inside hard ball work. His draw is pretty soft..

[4820]

I have been cosidering this decision for weeks. I've decided to go with Libba, I'll get it wrong I bet, so based on that Rocky will be the one to get  :-\

[BoredSaint]

Had the same decision but had Fyfe as well and had to choose 2. Ended up going Fyfe and Libba due to saving cash but I also think Libba could win the brownlow this year. The guy's a jet

#libba4charlie
#calleditfirst

[AaronKirk]

Rocky IMO. He is the third in line to be tagged while Libba, with the concerns about the injury the injury to Griffen, will be the first player likely to be tagged at the dogs.

[tor01doc]

Poll poll poll poll!

[Bully]

Such a tough decision, I'm in the Libba camp but only just. The deciding factor for me was the draw, the Doggies play only two finalists leading up to round 8 - Richmond & Carlton. Their all-important round 8 opponent is Melbourne, a team that Libba routinely spanks into oblivion. This could be critical in making up some lost ground with the absence of Gaz, Beams & Pendles.

[Hawks_1976]

Both will average within 5ppg of eachother so it doesn't matter who you pick.

If I had to choose though, I'd pick Libba. Just think his volume of contested footy is SC scoring gold.

[HotTiges]

Rocky just.signing new 3 year deal helps  8)

[Craze85]

Rocky named in fwd pocket  :-\

Do we know if he will play permanent midfield role this year?

[RaisyDaisy]

Rocky named in fwd pocket  :-\

Do we know if he will play permanent midfield role this year?

Don't worry about where they are named on Thursday night - he will spend most of the game in the mids

[WizzFizz]

Rocky named in fwd pocket  :-\

Do we know if he will play permanent midfield role this year?

Don't worry about where they are named on Thursday night - he will spend most of the game in the mids

Selwood was named on the HFF and played Rover all game and got 158 hmmmmm