Jacobs V Ryder

Started by James_Pies, March 18, 2014, 05:56:24 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

James_Pies

Who would be the better option?

kilbluff1985

neither imo would rather Big Boy for a bit more

Bully

Ryder should well while Belly is out but after that I wouldn't be so confident. Jacobs should be good for 85 avg but that won't be enough to compete with the stronger teams.

AaronKirk

neither are appealing options IMO- would rather spend a bit more on Leuey or Nic Nat

James_Pies



Cant afford anyone else unless you guys have any ideas on how can change my team around a bit.

JBs-Hawks

Lmac to georgiou, will that give you enough for Leuy or NN?

Bully

Your forwards look very weak, so why not bring in Hickey and upgrade Blease to Higgins or Hawkins?

James_Pies

Quote from: JBs-Hawks on March 18, 2014, 06:29:16 PM
Lmac to georgiou, will that give you enough for Leuy or NN?
I thought L Mac was a must though?

Higgins and Hawkins dont really appeal to me, thats why my forward line is pretty average. i'll upgrade them later :P

JBs-Hawks

Quote from: James_Pies on March 18, 2014, 06:32:39 PM
Quote from: JBs-Hawks on March 18, 2014, 06:29:16 PM
Lmac to georgiou, will that give you enough for Leuy or NN?
I thought L Mac was a must though?

Higgins and Hawkins dont really appeal to me, thats why my forward line is pretty average. i'll upgrade them later :P

Lmac might not even play rd 1.

RaisyDaisy

Don't like any of the mid priced rucks

Can you do Hickey, then McDonald to Georgiou and Blease to Dalhaus or Zorko?

Dudge

Suckling to Georgiou, play L Mac, Blease to Higgins, get Coxy. And this is from someone who has Suckling ( but $hitting bricks, and someone who's never had Higgins), so possibly disregard this post. Just throwing out a option

Craze85

X.Ellis to Georgiou by swinging Lmac to mids, opens up a mid/def link then get Leuy, Nicnat or Mcevoy
Or
Blease to Merret (if named)
Or
The Suckling change as Dudge said.

James_Pies

Is Leuy really much of an upgrade over Jacobs?

AaronKirk

Quote from: James_Pies on March 18, 2014, 10:57:05 PM
Is Leuy really much of an upgrade over Jacobs?

Leuey 10 tons from 20 games in 2013 and only 3 scores below 80 (2 of them were 79)
Jacobs 7 tons from 22 games in 2013 with 10 scores below 80





James_Pies

I could trade hurn out