Lobbe or Leuenburger for R1?

[Judd Magic]

Hi guys,

Wondering which one out of these 2 would you pick as your R1?

Kinda leaning towards Lobbe at the moment as I don't think there will be much difference score wise.

What does everyone else think?  :-\

[Grufflez]

People love Brissy in here, prepare for a lot of Luey Love.
Think im going Goldy at this stage but won't write off Luey or Nic Nat just yet

[billnats]

I got a decide between Leuey and NicNat before next week.

[Judd Magic]

People love Brissy in here, prepare for a lot of Luey Love.
Think im going Goldy at this stage but won't write off Luey or Nic Nat just yet

Yeah kinda expecting everyone to go with Burger but was just thinking that Lobbe also suits my bye structure more as he is round 9 bye where as Leuenburger and Sandi (who I have) both have the round 10 bye.  :-\

[frogjumper]

Of those 2 Leuy
I myself went Mumford which paid off.

[HappyDEZ]

Lobbe.

[Judd Magic]

Lobbe.

Whats your reasoning for Lobbe?

[kilbluff1985]

would pick Luey myself

[HappyDEZ]

Lobbe.

Whats your reasoning for Lobbe?

Clear No. 1 ruck at Port. On the up. Fights hard around the stoppages which earns him some contested ball & tackles.

[enzedder]

Lobbe.

Whats your reasoning for Lobbe?

Clear No. 1 ruck at Port. On the up. Fights hard around the stoppages which earns him some contested ball & tackles.

Same.
Lobbe. Tackling machine. No1 Ruck- sole ruck...Renouf emergency and not really a candidate to steal his spot. Redden LTI.
Think he'll average well.

[shaker]

With Renouf only emergency I went Lobbe but to be honest apart from Sandi none of the fancied rucks did much in the preseason think both should be ok but Lobbe just cheaper

[Jroo]

Berger for me.

[mabo]

With the promotion of Renouf, I'd be worried about picking Lobbe.

While he did finish the season out very strongly last year, it was during this time that he was the only ruck.

[Noz]

Renouf was on the senior list last year and still struggled to get games he won't bother Lobbe's scores at all. Right now Lobbe will be our clear number 1 ruck man and Hoff/Trengove will pinch hit in the rucks.

[Magic777]

Leuenburger, for me as he is the only main Ruckman in the Lions. Lobbe also has a tough run in the opening 5 rounds