Higgins or Caddy

[Swoozie]

Alright guys, so I'm tossing up between these two for F5.
Caddy may score better than Higgins given the lack of Motlop/Christensen and the time he'll play through the midfield.
We all know what Higgins can be like though so there is always an injury concern there.

However I don't exactly think Caddy will be a keeper, and there could be more cash generation from Higgins even if he averages less. A new role off half back could see him pumping out the scores anyway.

So do I go with Caddy, or go for Higgins and grab a little cash to use elsewhere in the team?

[kilbluff1985]

i think Caddy is the much safer bet

you could almost consider Caddy @F4 and Higgins @F5 though

[Swoozie]

you could almost consider Caddy @F4 and Higgins @F5 though

I was looking at this previously but it just looked too weak in the forwards for my liking. So I ended up going with Pav for F4 who is now locked out.
So unless I take one of Danger/Dusty/Parker out, I can only really afford to have one of them in.

[Blues Blues Blues]

you could almost consider Caddy @F4 and Higgins @F5 though

I was looking at this previously but it just looked too weak in the forwards for my liking. So I ended up going with Pav for F4 who is now locked out.
So unless I take one of Danger/Dusty/Parker out, I can only really afford to have one of them in.

Same predicament I had mate, so I downgraded Bennedy to Rohan, and used extra cash to upgrade Caddy to a premo. Now have Danger, Dusty, Roughy, Titchell, Higgins, Rohan which I'm happy with. Missy should make some coin hopefully.

[alldaylong]

Anybody having this dilemma before the cats play tonight?

Caddy with no sub risk, playing midfield and a durable body.

Higgins with a sub risk to begin the season with, sc friendly role off hb but I don't have to mention his body. 75k cheaper

Any change of hearts?
Any 100% reasons as to who to pick?

[E-Lemon_ator]

I have both but Caddy wins hands down IMO

[Samsturmfels]

I cant decide