Anyone else a little concerned with Caddy?

Started by Sydney14, March 14, 2014, 03:38:48 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Sydney14

I have Caddy at F5 and have had him there for awhile and thought nothing of it, but i've seen his SC scores in the NAB weren't that good. Against Melbourne he scored 121 DT but 94 SC and against Collingwood 84 DT and 61 SC.

94 isn't a bad score from him however it seems like he's gonna need to score 120+ DT to get a decent score in SC, maybe I'm just a bit tentative with the season so close to starting, but is his DE really bad or something?

Thinking of trading him down to Higgins.  :o

tor01doc


smashbox

also there 30 ppl playing in the NAB Cup so scores get deflated a bit, but nonetheless isnt a keeper so doesnt bother me

Spite

117 in the final practice match though so erase those doubts :)

Keeper27

how much do you bloody want your fwds to score?
how many fwds went over 100?? how many fwds are between 90-100??
Caddy is priced at 60. If he even goes 85 you'll make a sh!t load of money.

be realistic people. 

cortez

I'm expecting a 115 avg from him this year. Any less and he is out of my side!

Sydney14

Geez I'm not expecting 100's each week people, I'm saying if he scores 80-90 DT he'll probably only get 60-70 based on his score differences in the NAB.

cortez

Quote from: Sydney14 on March 14, 2014, 04:04:17 PM
Geez I'm not expecting 100's each week people, I'm saying if he scores 80-90 DT he'll probably only get 60-70 based on his score differences in the NAB.

If you look at his 3 nab scores though 61,94 & 117 that's an average of just over 90. You will get some 60s of course but you will also get some 90's and tonnes. That is why it's called an average.

Sydney14

Quote from: cortez on March 14, 2014, 04:09:38 PM
Quote from: Sydney14 on March 14, 2014, 04:04:17 PM
Geez I'm not expecting 100's each week people, I'm saying if he scores 80-90 DT he'll probably only get 60-70 based on his score differences in the NAB.

If you look at his 3 nab scores though 61,94 & 117 that's an average of just over 90. You will get some 60s of course but you will also get some 90's and tonnes. That is why it's called an average.

Well sorry I didn't see the 117 in the score archive on FF, that's where I went wrong, my bad. 

Ricochet

Averaged 106 per 100min in NAB. That's pretty damn good for his starting price

Sydney14

I am reassured now people, thank you  :)

SydneyRox

He isnt a keeper, but like Higgins, should increase enough to make a sideways or small increase to a real premium by mid year

Bully

Have to say that Caddy is the player I'm most worried about. For those expecting tons, you have have to temper your expectations a little. He's achieved the feat once in 40 games and even then he scraped in for an even 100. I've picked him because he's suitable for my structure but still not convinced he'll score more than an 80 avg.

Southstorm

If you look back to the second half of last year, he played 10 straight games from 14-23 for an average of 85. To make money off him, you don't even need him to improve, just find that form he finished in last year. My guess is he'll push that even further and average somewhere around 90. He's one of the safer mid-price picks, I'd only rate Beams as a safer investment.

Ricochet

Plus with Christensen and Motlop out he will attend more centre bounces and spend less time fwd