The Latest (rate 4 a rate)

Started by essendon, March 13, 2014, 11:54:17 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

essendon

let me know what you think! just some quick thoughts would be great

cash: $27 400

Def: J McVeigh, S MItchell, K Simpson, M Suckiling, L McDonald, W Langford (T Clurey, T Langdon)
Mids: G Ablett, S Pendlebury, T Rockcliff, D Beams, D Tyson, V Michie, J Polec, X Ellis ( L Dunstan, M Crouch)
Rucks: M Leuenberger, A Sandilands (D Currie, F Thurlow)
Forwards: P Dangerfield, D Martin, J Roughhead, L Franklin, J Caddy, G Rohan (M McDonough, J Kennedy-Harris)

Leave your link for a rate back!

Really appreciate it!


LMA12

defence is solid, im not a huge fan on kade, prefer enright or hanley to him
mids are solid, like rocky hes a gun,
ruck combo is good, currie probably wont get a game, pick a 102ker and save that 20k
forwards are strong, im not a massive fan for roughy this year as he is predominantly playing FF but still should score well

8/10

have a squizza at my side
http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,91485.0.html

LaHug

Couple of things. I'd say X. Ellis is a huge vest chance meaning you probably don't want him starting on your field. Mids are a bit weak with only 4 premiums... can't find a mid pricer in there? Forwards ridiculously strong! That's a whole lot of premiums! I'd probably try downgrading Buddy to someone cheaper and turning a mid rookie into someone like Daisey. Otherwise, very solid.

Knowall

Not a huge fan of having Mitchell, McVeigh, Simpson in the one side.  I dont think they represent great value as they are all up around 30 years of age now and i dont think youll see any improvement from them.  I understand they will likely be solid picks and there is bugger all other options but maybe someone with upside like Swallow is better than one of them.
I reckon Rockliff is a jet love that pick.  Ellis is good enough as a M8, shouldnt be hard to get 8 mids starting in the first few weeks.
I like Leuenberger (not a Brisbane fan btw lol).  Sandi is old and injury prone by 310k is good value.
FWDs very similar to mine.  I was thinking of picking ROughead but from memory last year when he played as a perm forward he didnt score very well.

essendon

im thinking to change buddy and roughhead, but i have no idea who for

maygs

I feel that Simpson may develop a less SC friendly role with Dockerty and Thomas in the team.  I would consider changing him.

I wouldn't swap Roughie out as I reckon he will be a gun again this year.

I have concerns regarding having both Tyson and Michie in the same team.  I reckon that they could both be shut down by good teams (and there are plenty of teams better than Melbourne).  I recommend just having one and spreading the risk to another player/team - maybe Aish or Roberston or Cripps

Please have a look at my team:

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,91586.0.html