Round 1 - Cats v Crows - March 20

[HotTiges]

For me its Roughy and Aish vs Libba and McCarthy

Although if I go with option 2 I am left with Rohan at fwd 5

Option 1 for sure..especially with Rohan F5!

[Vinny]

Yep no way I'd have Rohan at F5, I'm not liking him at F6. Good F7/8 though!

[RaisyDaisy]

I'm going to pass on McCarthy because I just see him being a low scorer - would rather JKH over him

As for HMac, no chance. The guy has played like 2 praccy games and will take time to get going, and there is every chance he gets rested in a week or two's time because it's guaranteed they will manage him

[cotch9]

For me its Roughy and Aish vs Libba and McCarthy

Although if I go with option 2 I am left with Rohan at fwd 5

Option 1 for sure..especially with Rohan F5!

Yeah thanks my forward line looked very weak with option 2

[HotTiges]

I'm going to pass on McCarthy because I just see him being a low scorer - would rather JKH over him

As for HMac, no chance. The guy has played like 2 praccy games and will take time to get going, and there is every chance he gets rested in a week or two's time because it's guaranteed they will manage him

Yeah Scott said he will in and out a bit this year RE HMac

[Ricochet]

I'm going to pass on McCarthy because I just see him being a low scorer - would rather JKH over him

As for HMac, no chance. The guy has played like 2 praccy games and will take time to get going, and there is every chance he gets rested in a week or two's time because it's guaranteed they will manage him

Yeah Scott said he will in and out a bit this year RE HMac

that was before Vardy went down with an ACL though

[Nige]

My boy LJ!  8)

[Ringo]

Also remember there is a match day thread for this match as well,

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,91034.msg1316953.html#new

[HotTiges]

I'm going to pass on McCarthy because I just see him being a low scorer - would rather JKH over him

As for HMac, no chance. The guy has played like 2 praccy games and will take time to get going, and there is every chance he gets rested in a week or two's time because it's guaranteed they will manage him

Yeah Scott said he will in and out a bit this year RE HMac

that was before Vardy went down with an ACL though

Good point still Simpson lurks as well. Depends if Scotty wants two dedicated rucks in the same team.for the moment it's no..

[RaisyDaisy]

Yeah I reckon Simpson and HMac will rotate early on with Blitzarse as backup

[Judd Magic]

Yeah I reckon Simpson and HMac will rotate early on with Blitzarse as backup

Spot on RD.

That's exactly what's going to happen IMO.

Therefore makes H-Mac too much of a risk to start with.

[all about winning]

I'm going to pass on McCarthy because I just see him being a low scorer - would rather JKH over him

Geelong have HUGE wraps on this kid., he is a big bodied midfielder that chris scott has got him playing up forward.
I watched him closley during the NAB cup and he is hard as nails.
It says allot if he doesnt start with the Vest.
I got a good feeling bout this rookie, hopefully RD can eat his words after 2nite  :D

[RaisyDaisy]

[I got a good feeling bout this rookie, hopefully RD can eat his words after 2nite  :D

More than happy to eat my words :)

I actually think his JS is not too bad at all - it's just his scoring potential that concerns me

[kilbluff1985]

so 6 Crows supporters have voted 8)

[Nige]

so 6 Crows supporters have voted 8)

tbag, Jay, CF, Grazz... who am I missing?  :P