Please Rate My Team!

[Tyrogue]

Late start this year, here's my first attempt:

BACK
McVeigh J, Mitchell S, Hanley P, Sallow D, Webster J, McDonald L (Martin B, Laidler J)

MIDFIELD
Ablett G, Liberatore T, Cotchin T, Thomas D, Shiels L, Tyson D, Polec J, Ellis X (Dunstan L, Crouch M)

RUCK
Cox D, Sandilands A (Currie D, Thurlow F)

FORWARD
Dangerfield P, Martin D, Hale D, Caddy J, Daniher J, Fasolo A (Rohan G, Kennedy-Harris J)

$900 left in the bank.

Updated! See here: http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,90878.msg1303956.html#msg1303956

[Blues Blues Blues]

Nice! I like this team!

Only weakness is Daniher and Fasolo at F5/6, can you squeeze Higgins in and move Rohan to F6?

[Tyrogue]

Nice! I like this team!

Only weakness is Daniher and Fasolo at F5/6, can you squeeze Higgins in and move Rohan to F6?

Was burned by Higgins for three seasons, will not risk taking him again. I'm quite comfortable with Daniher, I might look at downgrading either Swallow or Cox and upgrading Fasolo. Have you got any suggestions?  ;D

[Blues Blues Blues]

Nice! I like this team!

Only weakness is Daniher and Fasolo at F5/6, can you squeeze Higgins in and move Rohan to F6?

Was burned by Higgins for three seasons, will not risk taking him again. I'm quite comfortable with Daniher, I might look at downgrading either Swallow or Cox and upgrading Fasolo. Have you got any suggestions?  ;D

Ben Kennedy? Only 220k, should be regular in 22 I hope

[Tyrogue]

Here's an update, after downgrading Swallow to Suckling down back, and using the money to get Mitchell up forward. I have $22.5k left:

BACK
McVeigh J, Mitchell S, Hanley P, Suckling M, Webster J, McDonald L (Martin B, Laidler J)

MIDFIELD
Ablett G, Liberatore T, Cotchin T, Thomas D, Shiels L, Tyson D, Polec J, Ellis X (Dunstan L, Crouch M)

RUCK
Cox D, Sandilands A (Currie D, Thurlow F)

FORWARD
Dangerfield P, Martin D, Mitchell T, Hale D, Caddy J, Rohan G (Merrett Z, Kennedy-Harris J)

[cuz_crew]

much better

[hawkers65]

Here's an update, after downgrading Swallow to Suckling down back, and using the money to get Mitchell up forward. I have $22.5k left:

BACK
McVeigh J, Mitchell S, Hanley P, Suckling M, Webster J, McDonald L (Martin B, Laidler J)

MIDFIELD
Ablett G, Liberatore T, Cotchin T, Thomas D, Shiels L, Tyson D, Polec J, Ellis X (Dunstan L, Crouch M)

RUCK
Cox D, Sandilands A (Currie D, Thurlow F)

FORWARD
Dangerfield P, Martin D, Mitchell T, Hale D, Caddy J, Rohan G (Merrett Z, Kennedy-Harris J)

Solid team!

Backs: Good choices here, but i think i'd rather Simpson over Hanley and onsure on Webster (maybe because he burnt me last year) :P I think Martin and Laidler could be downgraded to Langford/Langdon/Georgiou/Clurey which will save you over 100k!

Mids: Way too riksy IMO! Only 3 premiums and one being a 21 year old... Plus no Beams? Try and get at least one of Shiels/Thomas to Beams if you can, then it won't look quite as weak. Trying to get Ellis is there some how would also be good.

Rucs: Solid! Not much too say. (Maybe go Cox to Leuey if you want some cash for your mids)

Fwds: Another good line, Hale is a good back up for Sandi if e gets injured. IMO don't like Titch, dont think he can keep up his preseason scores once all the Syd stars are back. Look elsewhere IMO. If Merret doesn't get up then go to Impey.

Not a bad effort, just fix your mids and you'll have a great team.

[Jmachete]

I agree you need to strengthen up those mids!

[Tyrogue]

Here's an update, after downgrading Swallow to Suckling down back, and using the money to get Mitchell up forward. I have $22.5k left:

BACK
McVeigh J, Mitchell S, Hanley P, Suckling M, Webster J, McDonald L (Martin B, Laidler J)

MIDFIELD
Ablett G, Liberatore T, Cotchin T, Thomas D, Shiels L, Tyson D, Polec J, Ellis X (Dunstan L, Crouch M)

RUCK
Cox D, Sandilands A (Currie D, Thurlow F)

FORWARD
Dangerfield P, Martin D, Mitchell T, Hale D, Caddy J, Rohan G (Merrett Z, Kennedy-Harris J)

Solid team!

Backs: Good choices here, but i think i'd rather Simpson over Hanley and onsure on Webster (maybe because he burnt me last year) :P I think Martin and Laidler could be downgraded to Langford/Langdon/Georgiou/Clurey which will save you over 100k!

Mids: Way too riksy IMO! Only 3 premiums and one being a 21 year old... Plus no Beams? Try and get at least one of Shiels/Thomas to Beams if you can, then it won't look quite as weak. Trying to get Ellis is there some how would also be good.

Rucs: Solid! Not much too say. (Maybe go Cox to Leuey if you want some cash for your mids)

Fwds: Another good line, Hale is a good back up for Sandi if e gets injured. IMO don't like Titch, dont think he can keep up his preseason scores once all the Syd stars are back. Look elsewhere IMO. If Merret doesn't get up then go to Impey.

Not a bad effort, just fix your mids and you'll have a great team.

Thanks, understand Liberatore is a bit of a risk, will likely drop him for someone else. What about going for a mid-priced R1 like HMac so I can upgrade one of Shiels/Thomas? Btw, being a Hawthorn supporter, don't you think Shiels might be a chance to breakout?