Caddy vs. Higgins

Started by Locandro, March 07, 2014, 04:49:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Southstorm


Keeper27

lets be honest, both aren't keepers.
Higgins priced @ 50, and Caddy @ 60, both can avg 80ish and get to 450K.

Higgins IMO is a better option the Bennedy.
Lets just hope he can stay on the park long enough for some good money.

RaisyDaisy

Although I feel a bit uneasy, I currently have both at F4/5 with Rohan at 6

With no fwd rookies we have to pay for JS, and if these two can average around 80 that's great. What I do actually like about start these two, is that besides Danger and Martin, picking fwd premos is such a headache, so its not bad to spend less on these guys, and by the time its time to upgrade them we will have a clearer picture of who the actual fwd premiums are going to be this year

Vinny

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on March 07, 2014, 09:45:54 PM
Although I feel a bit uneasy, I currently have both at F4/5 with Rohan at 6

With no fwd rookies we have to pay for JS, and if these two can average around 80 that's great. What I do actually like about start these two, is that besides Danger and Martin, picking fwd premos is such a headache, so its not bad to spend less on these guys, and by the time its time to upgrade them we will have a clearer picture of who the actual fwd premiums are going to be this year
Yep, exactly the same at F4, F5 and F6 for me.

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: Vinny on March 07, 2014, 09:46:55 PM
Quote from: RaisyDaisy on March 07, 2014, 09:45:54 PM
Although I feel a bit uneasy, I currently have both at F4/5 with Rohan at 6

With no fwd rookies we have to pay for JS, and if these two can average around 80 that's great. What I do actually like about start these two, is that besides Danger and Martin, picking fwd premos is such a headache, so its not bad to spend less on these guys, and by the time its time to upgrade them we will have a clearer picture of who the actual fwd premiums are going to be this year
Yep, exactly the same at F4, F5 and F6 for me.

Similar - I have Bennedy at F6 instead. Wondering if the $50k extra vs Rohan is worth it?

Vinny

I do not really rate Rohan at all but he has the JS and he will make you good cash, might even play JKH over him and bench.

Kennedy, I rate highly but I just think he will get vested heaps. I might be wrong but is he not the best candidate for the green/red vests? Plus, is he even Lock 22?

RaisyDaisy

Yeah I could turn Rohan into Bennedy too, and might even do so. With Coll play first we get to see if he starts sub, but bad luck if he gets the red vest

I don't want Rohan, but his JS and lack of options means we gotta take him

Blues Blues Blues

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on March 07, 2014, 10:33:04 PM
Yeah I could turn Rohan into Bennedy too, and might even do so. With Coll play first we get to see if he starts sub, but bad luck if he gets the red vest

I don't want Rohan, but his JS and lack of options means we gotta take him

Yeah, lucky named rd 1 Friday night so can assess sub position

Hoggyz_a_legend

With injuries to Motlop and Christensen, Caddy has been absolutely, 110% locked in my team. And since hearing he is fit, Higgins has been too. F5 and F6 atm.

roti

Can't think I can fit Higgins into F6, but he could break down at anytime so i'm sorta ok with it

jfitty

Trying to fit both of these guys in at the moment. Caddy F4, Higgins F5 and Rohan F6.

The magic question is who do we trust at F3 after Dangerfield and Dusty  ???

Judd Magic

Quote from: jfitty on March 08, 2014, 02:17:51 AM
Trying to fit both of these guys in at the moment. Caddy F4, Higgins F5 and Rohan F6.

The magic question is who do we trust at F3 after Dangerfield and Dusty  ???

Pavlich would be my guess.  8)

RaisyDaisy

Quote from: Judd Magic on March 08, 2014, 04:00:42 AM
Quote from: jfitty on March 08, 2014, 02:17:51 AM
Trying to fit both of these guys in at the moment. Caddy F4, Higgins F5 and Rohan F6.

The magic question is who do we trust at F3 after Dangerfield and Dusty  ???

Pavlich would be my guess.  8)

That's the exact 6 I am running with. Pav's price is why I have him over Buddy/JJK/anyone else as it allowed me to get a 4th prem defender, instead of a Dunn/Grimes priced defender

no eye deer

Quote from: RaisyDaisy on March 08, 2014, 05:39:23 AM
Quote from: Judd Magic on March 08, 2014, 04:00:42 AM
Quote from: jfitty on March 08, 2014, 02:17:51 AM
Trying to fit both of these guys in at the moment. Caddy F4, Higgins F5 and Rohan F6.

The magic question is who do we trust at F3 after Dangerfield and Dusty  ???

Pavlich would be my guess.  8)

That's the exact 6 I am running with. Pav's price is why I have him over Buddy/JJK/anyone else as it allowed me to get a 4th prem defender, instead of a Dunn/Grimes priced defender

Yep, I'm seriously considering starting without Buddy now and running with this. It will free up some needed cash and I'll jump on the Buddy train when (and if) it leaves the station.

Ricochet