Caddy vs. Higgins

[Locandro]

Who do you think will be the better pick out of these two this year?

[tor01doc]

Prob neither a keeper
Prob one will get injured - but when
Both could make money

I see their positions as one of the last selected so will depend on how much money left

Disclaimer - Higgins is on my never when list but I am still prepared to give him another chance

Currently have Higgins so I can afford Leue - but after first weekend of round 1 depending upon selections, Higgins may well go.

[juzztheball]

Prob neither a keeper
Prob one will get injured - but when
Both could make money

I see their positions as one of the last selected so will depend on how much money left

Disclaimer - Higgins is on my never when list but I am still prepared to give him another chance

Currently have Higgins so I can afford Leue - but after first weekend of round 1 depending upon selections, Higgins may well go.

Not sure i agree doc, i think if Higgins can get back to playing his best footy he could easily make the top 10 forward list, which would make him a keeper. I agree, its unlikely that he can play a whole season without another physical breakdown, but if he did manage it he's done enough to prove he knows where the pill is. Plus there seems to be a serious lack of quality fwd options this year which works in his favour...

[quinny88]

how much are you expecting him to average Juzz?  :o

Even with an injury free season he wont average more than mid 80's

Still worth a selection but deffinitely wont be a keeper

[nperera95]

Higgins with 33 disposals in todays practice match... Only question is how many games can he string together..

[enzedder]

Higgins.

[init4themoney]

Why not have both? Caddy will get more mid time with christensen and motlop injured. Averaged 75 last year without the vest. Can only get better

[billnats]

Interesting choice really... With Caddy, I can only afford McEvoy. But with Higgins, I can get big Cox... just dont want to be burnt by Higgins again.

[tor01doc]

Prob neither a keeper
Prob one will get injured - but when
Both could make money

I see their positions as one of the last selected so will depend on how much money left

Disclaimer - Higgins is on my never when list but I am still prepared to give him another chance

Currently have Higgins so I can afford Leue - but after first weekend of round 1 depending upon selections, Higgins may well go.

Not sure i agree doc, i think if Higgins can get back to playing his best footy he could easily make the top 10 forward list, which would make him a keeper. I agree, its unlikely that he can play a whole season without another physical breakdown, but if he did manage it he's done enough to prove he knows where the pill is. Plus there seems to be a serious lack of quality fwd options this year which works in his favour...

I would suggest you temper those wild expectations forthwith young man!

[juzztheball]

Okay maybe i went a bit over the top... but still, he's a genuine gun if he can string games together

[quinny88]

Okay maybe i went a bit over the top... but still, he's a genuine gun if he can string games together

Thats more like it :P

I dont doubt he is a gun, my concern with him aside from being injury prone is the role he will play.
The dogs mids have really formed in the past year or 2 so his time in the midfield will be less than ever.
Apparently he played across half back today though. Is that where you see him playing the season?

[juzztheball]

Wouldnt have thought so however he has played there in the past, and played well. Hopefully he can repay some of the faith we've put in him :)

[T Dog]

Wouldnt have thought so however he has played there in the past, and played well. Hopefully he can repay some of the faith we've put in him :)

or...no as usual.... :(

[quinny88]

Caddy up to 24 disposals at 3qtr time. Top possession winner on the ground.. Hmmm

[Keeper27]

Both in for now. F5/6