Rate For Rate :)

[rvp20]

Hey all, will do a rate for rate. Rate my team out of 40 (10 for Defence, 10 for Midfield, etc), leave the link to your team and I shall do the same. Thanks in advance! :)

DEF: J.McVeigh, S.Mitchell, C.Enright, M.Suckling, L.McDonald, J.Laidler (A.Georgiou, W.Langford)
MID: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J.Watson, M.Murphy, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J.Polec, L.Dunstan (X.Ellis, M.Crouch)
RUCK: A.Sandilands, H.McIntosh (F.Thurlow, T.Derickx)
FWD: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, J.Roughead, L.Franklin, G.Rohan, J.Kennedy-Harris (Z.Merrett, A.Spina)

Cash left: $1800

Rookies will change according to who will be playing in Round 1.

[rvp20]

Anyone?

[johnnytheboy1]

Hi Rvp20 you have a nice team there with a unique options
This is how i rate it.
Def: The unique pick here is Enright he keeps getting better with change, don't know where laidler fits in the Swans line up good choice of bench rookies. 7.5/10
Mids: Many premiums here which onley leaves 2 rookies on the field it would be better to trade down one of those premiums and get rookie like tyson in but if want your premiums then downgrade Thomas.8.5/10
Rucks I am considering Mcintosh as my 2nd ruck so it seems logical to pick if you are willing to take the chance. 7/10
Fwds: Roughead seems to have dropped off peoples radar so might a good pick here. JKH seems to be the best of the rookies. 7.5/10

I give your Team a  30.5 out of forty

[mark621]

def: solid rookies and the only one id query is enright, but if he gets back to his best why not! 7/10
Mid: pretty standard from what iv seen 9.5/10
ruck: mcintosh seems to be the highlighting figure, cant comment too much as i didnt see his nab game but in saying that, he shouldnt have too much competition for his spot. injury would be my worry 6/10
fwd: YES, yeah, yes, personally no, yes, and yes for the rest - buddy is my biggest worry at sydney, people love him but then people loved him last year and i loved not having him and winning many matches, in a side with that much competition and a team hes probably still getting used to. im personally avoiding still i see what he can do over 6-7 matches: 8.5/10

total: 31/40

[rvp20]

Thanks guys! Anyone else?  :)

[lachie_001]

Hey all, will do a rate for rate. Rate my team out of 40 (10 for Defence, 10 for Midfield, etc), leave the link to your team and I shall do the same. Thanks in advance! :)

DEF: J.McVeigh, S.Mitchell, C.Enright, M.Suckling, L.McDonald, J.Laidler (A.Georgiou, W.Langford)
MID: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J.Watson, M.Murphy, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J.Polec, L.Dunstan (X.Ellis, M.Crouch)
RUCK: A.Sandilands, H.McIntosh (F.Thurlow, T.Derickx)
FWD: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, J.Roughead, L.Franklin, G.Rohan, J.Kennedy-Harris (Z.Merrett, A.Spina)

Cash left: $1800

Rookies will change according to who will be playing in Round 1.

Defence is pretty solid I don't think Georgiou will start the season. Midfield is very strong, but I don't think Murphy will be able to get back to premium status this year. A lot of good rookies in the midfield maybe downgrade murphy to either tyson or michie? Im going with the same rucks, but I am still unsure whether McIntosh can start the season well. Forwards are okay, maybe upgrade one of your rookies, spina won't play at all this year so maybe find the cash to get in caddy. Which you might be able to do with downgrading murphy. Overall your team is good.
DEF - 8/10
MID - 9/10
RUC - 6/10
FWD - 6/10
Overall - 29/40

Rate mine at http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,90868.0.html cheers!

[cuz_crew]

McIntosh, Roughead & Franklin are not good

HMac - dont be a cheap skate... this guy has not played consistent football for 2 years.

Roughead will be playing in the goal square this year... not a mobile 2nd ruck anymore

Franklin - did you see him play last year? will be even worse in a stacked forward line up.

[Tyrogue]

Hey all, will do a rate for rate. Rate my team out of 40 (10 for Defence, 10 for Midfield, etc), leave the link to your team and I shall do the same. Thanks in advance! :)

DEF: J.McVeigh, S.Mitchell, C.Enright, M.Suckling, L.McDonald, J.Laidler (A.Georgiou, W.Langford)
MID: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J.Watson, M.Murphy, D.Beams, D.Thomas, J.Polec, L.Dunstan (X.Ellis, M.Crouch)
RUCK: A.Sandilands, H.McIntosh (F.Thurlow, T.Derickx)
FWD: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, J.Roughead, L.Franklin, G.Rohan, J.Kennedy-Harris (Z.Merrett, A.Spina)

Cash left: $1800

Rookies will change according to who will be playing in Round 1.

Backs - Not sold on Enright. He's consistent, but only way for him to go is down. I think there are better options for his projected output. 7.5/10
Mids - Very strong, I'd look at downgrading one of Pendles, Watson, or Murphy (Murphy preferably) and use the money elsewhere. 9/10
Rucks - Not sure HMac is a keeper. Okay if you intend to upgrade the rucks down the line. 6.5/10
Forwards - I'd wait at least a few games before getting Buddy, there are probably better options than Spina on the bench, and I'd probably take Hale or Gunston ahead of Roughy. 7.5/10

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,90878.0.html

[rvp20]

Made a few changes.


DEF: J.McVeigh, S.Mitchell, C.Enright, M.Suckling, L.McDonald, J.Laidler (A.Georgiou, W.Langford)
MID: G.Ablett, S.Pendlebury, J.Watson, D.Beams, D.Thomas, V.Michie, J.Polec, L.Dunstan (X.Ellis, M.Crouch)
RUCK: P.Ryder, A.Sandilands (F.Thurlow, T.Derickx)
FWD: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, J.Roughead, N.Riewoldt, G.Rohan, J.Kennedy-Harris (Z.Merrett, J.Impey)

Cash left: $79,700

Tossing up between N.Riewoldt and D.Petrie at F4. Any suggestions? :)

[AaronKirk]

Def: Not convinced about Laidler's JS. Relatively strong here though 8/10

Mid: Daisy to a premo or rookie. Rest strong 8/10

Ruck: Much better options than Ryder- get ready for a rollercoaster if you pick him 7/10

Fwd: Don't think Riewoldt is worth the risk in a poor St.Kilda side this year- Would prefer Gunston over Roughy. Need to upgrade Merrett to Caddy or Higgins. 7/10

Bit of work to do here 30/40

[cuz_crew]

Def: Not convinced about Laidler's JS. Relatively strong here though 8/10

Mid: Daisy to a premo or rookie. Rest strong 8/10

Ruck: Much better options than Ryder- get ready for a rollercoaster if you pick him 7/10

Fwd: Don't think Riewoldt is worth the risk in a poor St.Kilda side this year- Would prefer Gunston over Roughy. Need to upgrade Merrett to Caddy or Higgins. 7/10

Bit of work to do here 30/40

rubbish...

laidler will play every game and is at a bargain price

Daisy is an absolute a must have

[rvp20]

Should I go N.Riewoldt to D.Petrie??