Mike's Top 50

[shaker]

Haha it's obvious that father time has caught up with Mike and he is quite senile the funniest is Cloke at 7 and Sandi at 8 and yes Rockliff not there at all have checked twice but cannot see him  :o

[shaker]

Hawkins and JJK get a spot but no Cox ???

[Rusty00]

Surely this must be based on who he thinks will be the Top 50 this year given some of the inclusions and omissions?

Still doesn't explain Rockliff though :o Would love to hear his reasoning for leaving him out.

[ossie85]

Surely this must be based on who he thinks will be the Top 50 this year given some of the inclusions and omissions?

Still doesn't explain Rockliff though :o Would love to hear his reasoning for leaving him out.

^ that's exactly what it is.

Rockliff big oversight probably, but remember this is one man's opinion. Nothing more, the point is to raise discussion :)


You'd think Collingwood - with players in the top 7 + Beams + Sidebottom would be big premiership favourites. Unfortunately, we aren't.

[C.Judd3Votes]

Come on Mike, Billy Longer had a better year than Leuenburger??

[The_Captain]

bahahahahahah Hawkins at 35!!!!

and Motlop making top 50 is a joke. Plays 3 good games and is rated all of a sudden.

Back to the drawing board Sheehan!!!!

[Ringo]

Fair enough one mans rating but how he can not rank Rockliff in the top 50 when you look at some of the other players is beyond me.

Sandilands at 8 but no room for Cox at all another glaring anomoly.

[valkorum]

What about McPharlin - best CHB in the game and cant get a spot.

[Jroo]

Rockliff should be top 20, crazy how he didn't make the cut.
There's a few players I'd have ahead of Zaha, Heppell, Darling, Hendo and Sidey.

[The_Captain]

sloane in there as well.. bahahha thats a joke too. Played about 3 good games in his career.

[CrowsFan]

sloane in there as well.. bahahha thats a joke too. Played about 3 good games in his career.

Don't even know what to say to that. Clearly the stupidist thing I have read on here in some time, and yes I am including the cricket threads in that.

[The_Captain]

Theres no need for that HB. Rather than bite back because i am a far bigger person than you, I have reported you.

[Vinny]

Haha come on Noto, Sloane is actually a freak.

Don't say shower like that. ;)

Also HB, most stupid not stupidist.

[CrowsFan]

Also HB, most stupid not stupidist.

I think my bad grammar must have been why he reported me ;)

[ossie85]

Theres no need for that HB. Rather than bite back because i am a far bigger person than you, I have reported you.

For the record,  that is biting back.  Reporting good, but you still retaliated

Should note also that you implied sheahan was stupid for his opinion,  but didn't like it when someone did the same for you

Anyways,  constructive criticism by all is the way to go. ... no need for anyone (mods included) to get personal