Rate my supercoach and give me some tips :D

[alexg1993]

Backs - J McVeigh, S Mitchell, C Enright, M Suckling, L McDonald, M Fuller (T Cutler, T Vandeleur-only in cause cheap)

Midfield - G Ablett, S Pendulbry, D Swan, S Johnson, B Vince, D Thomas, J Polec, M Crouch (X Ellis, M Honeychurch)

Rucks - B Grundy, A Sandilands ( F Thurlow, M King - In cause cheap as)

Forwards - P Dangerfield, D Martin, J Roughead, S Higgins, J Kennedy-Harris, D Garlett (J Impey, S Tatupu - in cause cheap)

265,900 left in salary

Im not so sure with grundy yet but since being the main ruckman for the pies he should go alright

[ben_020285]

Ok, a few things.

Fuller won't play round 1 so replace him. Clurey, Langdon and Langford have played a bit in NAB so they are likely to play round 1.

You have too many mids that share the round 8 bye. Gaz, Pendles, Swan and Stevie J all share it. Also, where the hell is D Beams? At under 500k he is a must have but he also has the round 8 bye. I would be bringing in D Beams and holding on to Gaz and maybe Pendles. Get rid of Swan and Stevie J. If you want to have any chance at overall then you should swap a couple of them for round 9 or 10 bye players. Rockliff and Watson are popular choices.

Grundy is way too risky at R1. Swap him for a player that is likely to average 100 +

Higgins is a popular pick but he will get injured so keep that in mind. Garlett won't be playing for quite some time so scrap him for Rohan.

Having 265k left over is way too much so spend it on upgrades. leaving 20k - 50k is ideal to fix any rookies or other players in your team during the first few rounds before price increases.

Lastly, what's this 'only in cause cheap' business? You need to have rookies in that are actually playing for cash generation. It is ok to have one rookie in your side that's not playing for loophole purposes but that's it.

All the best.

[alexg1993]

thanks mate, what is your choice on mumford from the giants for a ruck choice?

[ben_020285]

thanks mate, what is your choice on mumford from the giants for a ruck choice?

I think he has potential to go 100 + but he has a history of niggling injuries and doesn't mind spitting the dummy on occasion and getting suspended. I expect him to miss a few games so he's not for me.

I think the best scoring ruckmen this year will be Minson, Goldstein, Cox, Naitanui and Sandilands. Sandi is obviously a must have at his price. Nic Nat is a lot cheaper than Minson, Goldy and Cox so if he is named round 1 he is probably the way to go. Will be interesting to see how he goes in this Thursday's practice match against Freo.

[Keeper27]

Backs - J McVeigh, S Mitchell, C Enright, M Suckling, L McDonald, M Fuller (T Cutler, T Vandeleur-only in cause cheap)
Midfield - G Ablett, S Pendulbry, D Swan, S Johnson, B Vince, D Thomas, J Polec, M Crouch (X Ellis, M Honeychurch)
Rucks - B Grundy, A Sandilands ( F Thurlow, M King - In cause cheap as)
Forwards - P Dangerfield, D Martin, J Roughead, S Higgins, J Kennedy-Harris, D Garlett (J Impey, S Tatupu - in cause cheap)

265,900 left in salary

DEF not sold on McVeigh @ that price, IMO will drop $$,Had enright in and out my team, good choice, suckers @ 4 is too risky, 2 rookies playing makes me uneasy, fuller wont play and no use having a cheapy @ d8 if he wont even play and make $$$. 5/10

MID wow, go all out. Love the M1-M4, super strong. SJ worries me will he give you 22 games?? Vince/Daisy will improve plenty. dunno how much Honey/crouchy will play early?? 8/10

RUC Grundilands is an ok cheap choice, Grundi should go 80ish. 6/10

FWD NO HIGGINS. your F6-F8 might not play. Garlett got issues, and Impey didnt impress. 5/10

OVERALL 24/40, it can be a lot better.




rate my team, any advice welcome