Rate my team and ill rate yours back

[Samsturmfels]

Mcveigh, Mitchell, Swallow, Suckling, Mcdonald, Laidler (Langford and Fuller)
Ablett, Pendlebury, Fyfe, Beams, Thomas, Martin, Michie, Ellis (Polec and Dunstan
Goldstein and Sandilands (Derickx and Lobb)
Dangerfield, Martin, Wingard, Wright, B.Kennedy and Rohan (Kenedy-Harris and HoneyChurch)
THE MORE OPINIONS THE BETTER

[Daniel123]

Seems solid on all lines but I don't think jack Martin is worth the cash.. I so think you could spend money better elsewhere by not starting with Goldstein

[frogjumper]

Defence: Solid. Possibly look at Clurey instead of Laidler/Fuller. 6/10
Midfield: Martin hasn't really proved much yet and his price is quite high. Maybe Dom Tyson or Matt Crouch 6/10
Rucks: Strong Goldstein is pricy, but also secure on a good average. Lobb hasn't played this preseason. 8/10
Forwards: Solid. Wingard is risky, but could payoff. Don't know much on B Kennedy so cant really say much here. Honeychurch unlikely to play. 7/10
Total 27/40

http://forum.fanfooty.com.au/index.php/topic,90299.0.html

[Footyrulz]

DEF: the players are good, though i think it's 1 rookie too many. 8/10
MID: almost identical to mine! no need for an expensive rookie on the bench 9/10
RUC: solid, get an MPP instead of lobb 9/10
FOR: very very risky. wingard could struggle in second year, wright is a massive risk and i doubt kennedy will play round 1. 6/10

Overall nice side but i think the forward line just needs a couple more safer options.

[ando_10]

DEF: the players are good, though i think it's 1 rookie too many. 8/10
MID: almost identical to mine! no need for an expensive rookie on the bench 9/10
RUC: solid, get an MPP instead of lobb 9/10
FOR: very very risky. wingard could struggle in second year, wright is a massive risk and i doubt kennedy will play round 1. 6/10

Overall nice side but i think the forward line just needs a couple more safer options.

wingard 2nd year? Huh?

[reesbr]

Kennedy will play round 1 for sure mate

[Footyrulz]

DEF: the players are good, though i think it's 1 rookie too many. 8/10
MID: almost identical to mine! no need for an expensive rookie on the bench 9/10
RUC: solid, get an MPP instead of lobb 9/10
FOR: very very risky. wingard could struggle in second year, wright is a massive risk and i doubt kennedy will play round 1. 6/10

Overall nice side but i think the forward line just needs a couple more safer options.

wingard 2nd year? Huh?

sorry i meant year after a breakout. think zorko

[Samsturmfels]

DEF: the players are good, though i think it's 1 rookie too many. 8/10
MID: almost identical to mine! no need for an expensive rookie on the bench 9/10
RUC: solid, get an MPP instead of lobb 9/10
FOR: very very risky. wingard could struggle in second year, wright is a massive risk and i doubt kennedy will play round 1. 6/10

Overall nice side but i think the forward line just needs a couple more safer options.

wingard 2nd year? Huh?

sorry i meant year after a breakout. think zorko

Last year it was Zorkos 2nd year

[Footyrulz]

DEF: the players are good, though i think it's 1 rookie too many. 8/10
MID: almost identical to mine! no need for an expensive rookie on the bench 9/10
RUC: solid, get an MPP instead of lobb 9/10
FOR: very very risky. wingard could struggle in second year, wright is a massive risk and i doubt kennedy will play round 1. 6/10

Overall nice side but i think the forward line just needs a couple more safer options.

wingard 2nd year? Huh?

sorry i meant year after a breakout. think zorko

Last year it was Zorkos 2nd year

Yes but it was his breakout year. Players very often drop off after their breakout.

Some examples of players in their 3rd or 4th year are:

Matthew Wright, Shane Savage and Lewis Jetta.

Many have fallen off after breaking out. Wingard is too risky i reckon.

[Samsturmfels]

ok......

[love4thegame]

Mcveigh, Mitchell, Swallow, Suckling, Mcdonald, Laidler (Langford and Fuller)
Ablett, Pendlebury, Fyfe, Beams, Thomas, Martin, Michie, Ellis (Polec and Dunstan
Goldstein and Sandilands (Derickx and Lobb)
Dangerfield, Martin, Wingard, Wright, B.Kennedy and Rohan (Kenedy-Harris and HoneyChurch)
THE MORE OPINIONS THE BETTER

as I've said to many others I'm not sold on swallow because the evidence just isn't there to justify his mid price,  also laidler had a not bad nab game but he's an average player trying to break into Sydney, I don't like that! Other than that I really like your team

[Samsturmfels]

Mcveigh, Mitchell, Swallow, Suckling, Mcdonald, Laidler (Langford and Fuller)
Ablett, Pendlebury, Fyfe, Beams, Thomas, Martin, Michie, Ellis (Polec and Dunstan
Goldstein and Sandilands (Derickx and Lobb)
Dangerfield, Martin, Wingard, Wright, B.Kennedy and Rohan (Kenedy-Harris and HoneyChurch)
THE MORE OPINIONS THE BETTER

as I've said to many others I'm not sold on swallow because the evidence just isn't there to justify his mid price,  also laidler had a not bad nab game but he's an average player trying to break into Sydney, I don't like that! Other than that I really like your team

1st off, Swallow is a good price, which i heard he will be also be moving into the midfield + he was pick 1 in the 2010 which proves he has good potential, I also heard he's improved a lot over the off season.

2. Who is a better option than Laidler

[frogjumper]

I heard the same thing about Swallow. Im willing to take the risk, as are a lot of people I know of.

I Don't see many choices in backline better than Laidler. No rookie really has JS. Almost have to wait for the squads so we have a better idea of who may play.

[love4thegame]

Mcveigh, Mitchell, Swallow, Suckling, Mcdonald, Laidler (Langford and Fuller)
Ablett, Pendlebury, Fyfe, Beams, Thomas, Martin, Michie, Ellis (Polec and Dunstan
Goldstein and Sandilands (Derickx and Lobb)
Dangerfield, Martin, Wingard, Wright, B.Kennedy and Rohan (Kenedy-Harris and HoneyChurch)
THE MORE OPINIONS THE BETTER

as I've said to many others I'm not sold on swallow because the evidence just isn't there to justify his mid price,  also laidler had a not bad nab game but he's an average player trying to break into Sydney, I don't like that! Other than that I really like your team

1st off, Swallow is a good price, which i heard he will be also be moving into the midfield + he was pick 1 in the 2010 which proves he has good potential, I also heard he's improved a lot over the off season.

2. Who is a better option than Laidler

each to there own mate ;) also for laidler there is georgiou(if he gets elevated), clurey and Langdon IMO

[Samsturmfels]

Mcveigh, Mitchell, Swallow, Suckling, Mcdonald, B.Martin (Langford and Fuller)
Ablett, Pendlebury, Fyfe, Beams, Thomas, Vince, Michie, Ellis (Polec and Dunstan)
Ryder and Sandilands (Derickx and Lobb)
Dangerfield, Martin, Dahlhaus, Wright, Higgins and Rohan (Kenedy-Harris and HoneyChurch)
THE MORE OPINIONS THE BETTER
In: B.Martin, Vince, Ryder, Dahlhaus and Higgins
Out: Laidler, J.Martin, Goldstein, Wingward and B.kennedy