Lewis vs Scotty Thompson...HELP!

[craftcoat]

Hey guys, i just can't seem to make a decision on these two as my 3rd mid. Some help would be much appreciated.

Jordan Lewis (411k) vs Scotty Thompson (430k)??

-with Lewis there seems to be far more upside and looks fitter this year...
-Scotty is a seasoned gun who's reliable and can produce huge scores.

Who's the better pick ??   cheers

[morro4]

go lewis. i just feel thompson is on the decline.

[elephants]

lewis if he doesnt slap someone or scotty thompson who is IMO the most consistent player in the AFL

[Justin Bieber]

lewis with more upside in him. thompson is consistent but hasn't taken that next step. also is said to be playing a little more up forward in his spare time on field.

if you like to take a gamble, lewis or if you want to be safe, thompson.

[CFC 1979]

Scores to date

Thompson 60 58   ave 59
Lewis       94 73    ave 83.5