Buddy + Macrae Vs Caddy + Murphy

[colmullet]

Both Buddy and Murphy have shown they can go 110+.....who knows how Buddy will fit in to the Swans....who knows how Murphy will handle tags this year

Both Caddy and Macrae have shown they have the potential to make decent coin while providing decent scores

Finding it hard to split these two choices.

[Doggoneit]

IMO I think you are better off with the Mid pricer in the forwards rather than midfield.

Buddy will be a stay at home forward at the Swans, especially with Tippett out. Very risky.

I'm not sold on Murphy - I know he has had elite scores in the past but there's something about him i find "soft". 

[Nige]

Macrae's a second year player, picking him is just asking for trouble.

I've never been a Murphy fan, just tend to agree with Doggoneit... but he'd be a more reliable option than Macrae any day of the week (this year anyway).

So, with that, I don't really like either option too much.

However, Caddy and Murphy is definitely the safer option.

[shaker]

Have not seen enough of Buddy at the swans yet and don't know a great deal about Macrae apart from his last score so would have to go with Murph and Caddy

[H1bb3i2d]

Don't pick Buddy expecting him to score 110+... Take a 100 from him any day, 10 points underpriced and enough to be a top 6-10 forward
Murphy *could* go 110+, I doubt it though... probably safe for a 105-110 return, which is good but won't cut it for a top 10 MID, and won't make enough coin to be worth it IMHO.

Buddy and Shiels

[colmullet]

Thankx guys

Everything will be much easier if a cheap rookie or two pop up for round 1