Shiels vs daisy

[dano_monaz]

Shiels preseason form making me question Daisy's spot at m5

[GoLions]

I really like Shiels as a POD option but Daisy (assuming he stays injury free) is a much safer bet to score well and become a stepping stone to a fallen premium.

[roti]

If Langford gets a game as a tagger thats great news on the rookie front, an added bonus for that is Shiels gets unleashed, could well average 100 if that is the case, something too look out for

[ben_020285]

If we could be certain that Shiels wasn't going to be a tagger this year then it would be a coin flip. Unfortunately we can't be sure of that so Daisy is the way to go.

[eaglesman]

lads they are also not the same price .. daisy wins on that alone

[GoLions]

lads they are also not the same price .. daisy wins on that alone

Shiels is 10k cheaper...

[eaglesman]

lads they are also not the same price .. daisy wins on that alone

Shiels is 10k cheaper...

hahahaha my bad i thought we were talking sheil! sorry everybody ... continue on

in that case ... Radar just got perked up ... sheils has been owning this preseason

[GoLions]

lads they are also not the same price .. daisy wins on that alone

Shiels is 10k cheaper...

hahahaha my bad i thought we were talking sheil! sorry everybody ... continue on

in that case ... Radar just got perked up ... sheils has been owning this preseason

haha no worries mate :P
He has been very good, keeping an eye on him

[eaglesman]

what we must ask ourselves is ... what has changed at the hawks for shiels to be playing a different role?

No Buddy
No Savage
No Guerra (filled by suckers)
No Ellis(barely played anyways)
No Osborne(didnt play basically)

In Mcevoy
In a bunch of rookies
Cyril playing defense

Any of the hawks mids becoming old and cant run it out any more?

[dano_monaz]

If Langford becomes the new hawks tagger I think I'll be going Shiels! Just need that inside word haha

[tor01doc]

what we must ask ourselves is ... what has changed at the hawks for shiels to be playing a different role?

No Buddy
No Savage
No Guerra (filled by suckers)
No Ellis(barely played anyways)
No Osborne(didnt play basically)

In Mcevoy
In a bunch of rookies
Cyril playing defense

Any of the hawks mids becoming old and cant run it out any more?

A coming of age?

[dano_monaz]

Well I reckon Sewell / Lewis are a chance to not run out games as much, which will hopefully mean more time onball for Shielsy

[tor01doc]

Yes, but if he covers for Sewell, it'll be primarily a negating role I think.

[HotTiges]

don't mind Shiels, if you had a 2nd team you'd pick him!

[tor01doc]

Richmond is my second team - you take him.