The Dominators with 100k in the coffers

Started by toodledock, March 11, 2010, 08:18:42 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

toodledock

Dont often go for feedback outside my own head, but criticize my team please.

B: Goddard, Enright, Newman, Shaw, Hodge, Greenwood, Waters
(Maguire, Silvagni)

C: Ablett, Dal Santo, Mitchell, Martin, Barlow, Banner
(Trendgove, Shuey)

R: Sandi, Nicnat (Warnock, Lobbe)

F: Riewoldt, Pavlich, Franklin, Tippit, Hall, Ziebell, Gumbleton
(Rockliff, Pods)


-Thinking about dumping Shaw for Hunt, and Gumbleton for Dangerfield as forward rookies are so meh.

spike#12

i wouldnt have banner to start if i where you.

CFC 1979

Gumby is a dumby
Newman is a backstabber
Dal santo loves himself
Hall can't do it all

seriously
Put Tippett in the ruck.
Loose gumby.. Put rock on field. Buy cheaper foward
Waters a worry with injury

Just a quick veiw

alman

Strong looking side mate - 9/10

Usual risks associated with 3 starting rookies in the mid - hoping they all play! But trengrove on the bench is perfect cover if banner or barlow don't play.

Biggest criticism (as their isn't much else to criticize) is both gumbleton and waters starting - i think possibly downgrading shaw/newman (as i'm not convinced on him) to hunt like you suggested and upgrading BOTH waters and gumbleton. Are a few cheap options for ugrading such as greenwood BACK and ballantyne or westhoff (roughy) FOR.

Resch

Don't think - DO!!

Both those thought's improve your team IMO

You are either on the NicNat bandwagon or not - I'm not.

Similarly with the 5 rookie midfield bandwagon - Not one I am on (any more  ;) )

lowedown11

dont like gumby starting....and waters although i reckon he is a gun maybe on the bench for nowjust to start