Please Rate My SC 2014

[cuz]

I have gone for a lot of players that are expected to improve significantly on last year and go for an early cash grab. I Like my backline, mids and ruck however my forward line looks exposed with White, Yarran, Clarke and Bock. I think Gunston will win the coleman.

Backs:

S Mitchell, H Shaw, D Swallow, J Carlisle, R Harwood, S Docherty (J Tippett, M Fuller)

Mids

D Swan, D Martin, D Beams, J O'Meara, J Trengove, S Savage, J Caddy, X Ellis (A Morabito, D Garlett)

Rucks

M Pyke, M Lobbe (F Thurlow, D Garlett)

Forwards

J Westhoff, J Gunston, J White, C Yarran, M Clark, N Bock (L Taylor, M Honeychurch)


$600 remaining

[Rowan1812]

Where do i start.
H shaw will be tagged big time at GWS.
Carlisle is going to be inconsistent.
Harwood not proven.
Docherty injured for 4 more weeks
Tippet may not get a game early. Even if he does, he wont score well.
Fuller hasn't played in either NAB challenge game so wont play round 1.
O'meara wont be a keeper and is too expensive.
Trengove is useless.
Better options than Savage at his price.
Morabito wont play round 1 neither will Garlett.
Lobbe wont be a keeper and is too awkwardly priced.
Yarran is too up and down.
Mitch Clark is injured and wont play round 1.
Bock wont be back until about round 3.

[cuz]

I have made some changes however I disagree on a few things.

Obviously the rookies will be adjusted at round 1.

- Harwood is going to rack up 20 + touches per week.
- Lobbe has just joined the 6 man leadership group and will have a big year
- Morabito will play early in 2014. I know one of the players and he's on track.
- Savage will play 22 games now that he's a saint (if he stays fit)
- Yarran is due. It's a punt but there is huge talent.

Backs:

S Mitchell, K Simpson, D Swallow, R Harwood, M Suckling, L McDonald (J Tippett, T Langdon)

Mids

J Selwood, D Swan, D Martin, D Beams, S Savage, V Michie J Polec, X Ellis (J O'Rourke, D Garlett)

Rucks

M Pyke, M Lobbe (F Thurlow, D Garlett)

Forwards

J Westhoff, L Franklin, J Gunston, S Crameri, J White, C Yarran,  (L Taylor, M Honeychurch)

[Griffo1982]

Far too many risks taken on non proven SC scorers.
Harwood
Swallow
Savage
Pyke
Lobbe
Gunstan
Crameri
White
Yarran

There is merit in picking Swallow, Savage(he's in my team), Lobbe, Gunstan but i'd only be taking a punt on 2 or at the most 3 of them.

[cuz]

Ok so with all of this in mind - can you rattle off a few 300-400K locks?

[cuz]

Backs:

S Mitchell, K Simpson, D Swallow, R Harwood, M Suckling, L McDonald (J Tippett, T Langdon)

Mids

G Ablett , D Swan, D Martin, D Beams, J Watson, V Michie J Polec, X Ellis (J O'Rourke, M Crouch)

Rucks

T Hickey, M Lobbe (F Thurlow, T Nankervis)

Forwards

P Dangerfield, L Franklin, J Gunston, J Caddy, T Walker, G Rohan  (L Taylor, M Honeychurch)

$80,700 left

[Rowan1812]

You do know walker might not be back until round 15?

[greco272]

Lobbe is Sh*t

Walker NO

Mids are really beast..!