Big unit of a team, feedback baby!

[dano_monaz]

Any feedback would be lovely

Backs: Hanley Mitchell hibberd suckling Delaney fuller (Langford / aliir)

Mids: Ablett pendles selwood beams Thomas Tyson Kelly aish (beams / polec)

Rucks: Pyke sandilands (wood / derickx)

Forwards: danger roughy Parker caddy hogan Rohan (garlett / Kennedy-Harris)

Still keen to play with rookies so happy to take any advice on board

[dano_monaz]

Ps liked clurey tonight as a rookie back

[Maggie May]

Backs: First 4 fine.  Not sure which Delaney you mean but think there are better options out there for that price.  Your rookies need work as I think there are better ones presented so far this preseason.  You could consider McDonald, Martin, Clurey, Langdon and Georgiou off the top of my head.  So far Fuller hasn't got a game and Aliir may find it hard to break into the Swans backline with several players returning from injury.  Langford has looked good so far though.

Mids: Not a fan of Kelly, Think there is better value, and beams & Polec are too much cash on the bench.  Dunstan, Crouch and Robertson have all shown a bit and are much better value for bench options.  I'd personally look at downgrading Kelly & Beams to two of those options and use the cash elsewhere.  Hard to fault your first 4 but Thomas makes me nervous.  He should be a cash cow if his ankle holds out but not sure he'll be a keeper. 

Ruck: Pyke a nice POD.  Not sure about Wood's job security and that is a lot of cash on the bench not earning you points.

Forwards:  Reckon you should look at getting Dusty in there if you can, but your first 3 look fine.  Not sure about the Caddy/Hogan/Rohan combo though.  Reckon you might want to try and upgrade one.  As for your rookies JKH is fine but am not liking the job prospects for Garlett early as has yet to play a pre-season game for the Hawks.  Plenty are still picking him though.

[tor01doc]

Hibberd hammy twang tonight so watch.
Rookies need fine tuning pending selection but McDonald the roo looks likely despite his slightly high price.

Bye trouble round 8 can be avoided by getting Watson instead of Selwood.
Get cheaper mid benchies - Crouch might play / Honeychurch might / Dunstan

Pyke is either a fish or a dive - not an R1.

Dusty is required.

Good luck.

[dano_monaz]

Thanks guys made a couple of rookie changes etc
Looks way more balanced