Rucks Rucks Rucks...

[shorty3264]

Mumford's end to 2013 was certainly impressive. Also averaged 112 in 2011 I believe, so he too can go big. Will Giles still have much of a role to play? I'm leaning towards Mummy at this point. Not trusting Sauce, I'm still receiving treatment for the burns last year..

[locknload10]

Stay away from McEvoy.
He was a work horse at St Kilda being the sole ruck... at Hawthorn his load is significantly reduced with Hale still on the team.
Much better options at his price.

[sammy123]

Have mcevoy atm but tossing up luey

[Grufflez]

Myke Pyke is the answer to a durable option, and will become a solid scorer in Mumfords absense

How Solid? willing to throw a prediction/Guesstimate out there

[Purplehaze25]

Myke Pyke is the answer to a durable option, and will become a solid scorer in Mumfords absense

How Solid? willing to throw a prediction/Guesstimate out there

My prediction - 90-100 avg
Although that could be wishful thinking? ;)

[cortez]

I've bitten the bullet, downgraded Tyson to a rookie priced mid and have gone with Minson. No more worrying for me!

[ubeaut]

I like Mumford but is there enough improvement at GWS for players to average 100 - 110+?

Highest last year was Ward I think with 97 then Treloar with 87.

Also does Giles play? If not who?

These are the questions that keep me from picking Mumford. If he was cheaper Lock but at the price I'd rather just be safe and pay more for Minson.

[GoLions]

I like Mumford but is there enough improvement at GWS for players to average 100 - 110+?

Highest last year was Ward I think with 97 then Treloar with 87.

Also does Giles play? If not who?

These are the questions that keep me from picking Mumford. If he was cheaper Lock but at the price I'd rather just be safe and pay more for Minson.

Pretty sure Ward averaged 100+ the year before last? And with so many people still improving and not quite up there with the best, those who are already experienced definitely can push for that 100+ average. Personally I think Mummy will average around the 95 mark, but that's not due to him being at GWS.

[RaisyDaisy]

Maybe its that angry Mafia profile picture that gives people the wrong impression of you mate..have you considered an adorable  puppy?

LOL! Fair call

Paulie Walnuts is here to stay!

[RaisyDaisy]

I've bitten the bullet, downgraded Tyson to a rookie priced mid and have gone with Minson. No more worrying for me!

LOL, 24 hours ago you where convincing us how much value Dawson Simpson was

Ahhh the fun and joys of SC, we change our minds so often!  :D

[eaglesman]

If you don't start Aaron sandilands stop playing supercoach now .... Because you are an idiot .... Let that be the end of r2 debates

[Vinny]

Was this thread necessary..haha?

[eaglesman]

The ruck debate is pretty much the hottest topic on Fanfooty I think ... Half of those positions are finished ... Sandilands will be 500-550k in no time

[Vinny]

Haha yeah you are right but just saying on this page alone there is 5 ruck threads created. It's alright though Nevermind.

[eaglesman]

That is kind of my point haha ... F5 f6 d5 and d6 are much harder spots to fill imo