Matt Wright vs Josh Caddy

[WizzFizz]

Which player will score more this year and why?

[Grufflez]

I have absolutely no clue sorry  :P

[storeymjs]

Wright for me. The reason being that Caddy hasn't shown that he can score super well. He will be playing in a team which although is ageing still has a very good midfield. Wright on the other hand has proven he score and average 95+. For this reason I would choose him over Caddy (but he is more expensive) :)

[HotTiges]

Tough call do you have Danger in the FWDS as well?

[Woppa15]

Caddy for mine. Was touted as having more midfield responsibility this year and now that Motlop and Christensen are both out untill mid year that prospect only increases.

Wright may well end up with a run with role or tagging role once the real thing starts, just like every other year.

Caddy on the other hand will never tag, that responsibility goes to Hunt.

[Ricochet]

I think Wright may average just a little more but the risk of him getting tagging jobs is really putting a lot off.
Caddy is the safer option because he is cheaper

[Keeper27]

geez all tied up, was hoping for caddy to be the clear winner.

[WizzFizz]

Yea I'd be taking Jcad this year as he is bigger, cheaper, and can fill many of the injured cats' roles as an onballer like Christensen and selwood.

[RaisyDaisy]

Pretty much what the others have said. Caddy would be the safer option, and Motlop and Christensen out only helps him more

I think Wright's role will change week to week pending opposition

[gogonz]

I'm taking both

[BoredSaint]

I had Wright but worried he might drop off again like last season. Was tempted to grab both but that leaves me with Wright at F3 and Caddy at F4 which is a tad risky if both fail.

Atm im leaning towards Caddy seeing as hes had a pretty good pre-season and also looks to be running through the midfield. And with Selwood out for a couple of weeks and also a few of their other midfielders beginning to age, I can really see him becoming their next A grade midfielder. Don't think he'll cop a tag either once Selwood comes back

[Bully]

With Selwood going down I'm banking on Caddy to step up. I've just downgraded Mitchell to Caddy and upgraded Robertson to Tyson.

[rebird]

Wright also has greater opportunity with Vince, van Berlo and Brodie smith missing from last year

[gogonz]

Wright also has greater opportunity with Vince, van Berlo and Brodie smith missing from last year

This!

[Vinny]

But the way I see it, Van Berlo being out almost makes him a certainty to tag in the normal season.