Ask Nrich

Started by nrich102, February 24, 2014, 09:59:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

blues boy

Quote from: nrich102 on February 25, 2014, 08:30:32 PM
Quote from: blues boy on February 25, 2014, 08:50:54 AM
Would love to get your thoughts on

Cotchin v Watson

Also do you think Fuller and Laidler are good D7 and D8 options? If not who would you choose?

Cheers mate
Should both average the same. Cotchin just cause hes cheaper

What other backline rookies do you have mate?

Just Luke Mcdonald, i know K. Kolo is solid but i mean anyone under 150K?

Matt_352

Kade Simpson v anyone else around that range ?

And what do you make of lobbes performance v essendon ?

Who do you rate as the best two to have at D7 & D8? Cutler, Clurey, Ashby, Fuller, Laidler, Langdon, Giorgiou are the ones ive been looking at.

nrich102

#17
Quote from: blues boy on February 26, 2014, 12:00:04 AM
Quote from: nrich102 on February 25, 2014, 08:30:32 PM
Quote from: blues boy on February 25, 2014, 08:50:54 AM
Would love to get your thoughts on

Cotchin v Watson

Also do you think Fuller and Laidler are good D7 and D8 options? If not who would you choose?

Cheers mate
Should both average the same. Cotchin just cause hes cheaper

What other backline rookies do you have mate?

Just Luke Mcdonald, i know K. Kolo is solid but i mean anyone under 150K?
Not that many great options under 150k. Spud Tippett will probably get games, but dont expect much score wise. Tom Clurey (163k) Lachie Plowman (180k) and Sam Shaw (200k) all have a decent chance of game time and are in the 150-200k range.

nrich102

Quote from: Matt_352 on February 26, 2014, 09:59:14 AM
Kade Simpson v anyone else around that range ?

And what do you make of lobbes performance v essendon ?

Who do you rate as the best two to have at D7 & D8? Cutler, Clurey, Ashby, Fuller, Laidler, Langdon, Giorgiou are the ones ive been looking at.
1. The only other option Id consider around Simpsons price (440k-480k) would probably be Hanley and maybe Heath Shaw if youre in a Heath Shaw mood. For me it would be out of Hanley and Simpson.

2. Ouch... Thats a shocking score. Just 5 disposals, with 4 of them by hand. Im not completely put off by this score though. NAB Challenge could mean anything.

3. Probably Clurey and Laidler

Matt_352

If i can turn one of hanley or simpson to mcveigh should i and which one already have sitchell

Already have simpson and hanley btw

blues boy

Is having Titchell, Franklin and Rohan all in the forward line too much? will they affect each others scoring?

truBLUE

Got to ask mate who do you see avg more Gunston , franklin , pav cheers mate

nrich102

Quote from: Matt_352 on February 27, 2014, 12:56:30 AM
If i can turn one of hanley or simpson to mcveigh should i and which one already have sitchell

Already have simpson and hanley btw
Lets break it down.

Pearce Hanley
2013 Games: 20
2013 Average: 85.5
2013 High score: 129
2013 Hundreds: 5
2013 Low Score: 35
2013 Scores >50: 3 (1 Subbed)

Kade Simpson
2013 Games: 22
2013 Average: 85.2
2013 High Score: 127
2013 Hundreds: 7
2013 Low Score: 46
2013 Scores >50: 1 :o

Very Very Similar. Tbh Im getting these 2 instead of McViegh.

nrich102

Quote from: blues boy on February 27, 2014, 02:42:37 PM
Is having Titchell, Franklin and Rohan all in the forward line too much? will they affect each others scoring?
effect*

I dont think that Mitchell/Rohan will effect Buddys scoring, but Rohan my take a couple (probably not many) points off Titchell. There are probably better options instead of Rohan though.

nrich102

Quote from: truBLUE on February 27, 2014, 04:53:39 PM
Got to ask mate who do you see avg more Gunston , franklin , pav cheers mate
Buddy Mate

Money

#25
Hey Nrich, just a question for ya

If both Polec and Ellis are named R1 (looking likely at the moment) is it worth taking the punt and fielding one of them and benching another starter around 135k,

for eg Michie, Beams, Ellis (Polec, Cunningham (possibly)

nrich102

Quote from: Money on February 27, 2014, 10:18:09 PM
Hey Nrich, just a question for ya

If both Polec and Ellis are named R1 (looking likely at the moment) is it worth taking the punt and fielding one of them and benching another starter around 135k,

for eg Michie, Beams, Ellis (Polec, Cunningham (possibly)
Hey mate, I think there's a high chance Beams will be sub, so if Polec can go on scoring what he is, pick him over Beams.

truBLUE

Another one for you nrich who do you think would be a better option at D6 L McDonald or S shaw  what do you think there avgs might be  cheers in advance  :)

pommyadam

#28
should I pick Watts as a DEF or FWD?

The It

Zorko vs. Franklin, thanks!!