I want EVERYONES advice and opinions good or bad

[50kismine]

def: A.Walker, J.Mcveigh, G.Ibbotson, T.Mckenzie, L.Mcdonald, M.Fuller (J.Tippett,T.Cutler)

mid: J.Steven, T.Liberatore, N.Fyfe, D.Beams, B.Ellis, J.Martin, J.Aish, V.Michie (T.Langdon, M.Honey-Church)

ruc: S.Jacobs, A.Sandilands (D.Currie, T.Derickx)

fwd: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, C.Dixon, T.Mitchell, J.Lamb, J.Hogan (D.Garlett, J.Kennedy-Harris)

$2,600 cap left
rates and opinions pleaseee

[Doggoneit]

Like

Ibbotson as a POD

Dont like

Mids - way too risky - all 5 of your premiums you need to step up another cog to reach Elite status and very unlikely they will all do that

Jacobs - better options

Also not sure why you only have $2600 left as overall the premiums look very weak - you might need to get rid of Martin and Hogan for some cheaper options - eg Hogan to Blease and Martin to Ellis

[nick wilkesmann]

ruck and mids way too weak

[50kismine]

ruck and mids way too weak

I understand that the mids weak but im going on potential this year Stevens and Libba will rack in the big points and I reckon the strength in my fwd/back will pick up anyone that lacks behind in my mids.  I reckon Libba and Stevens will be in the top 10 mids in the comp by the end of the year.

[shaker]

Every line looks risky to me but if your happy with it that's all that matters cheers

[nick wilkesmann]

no prob with steven and libba, they are good picks and you're probably right on them being top 10 at end of year, the only problem is that they are your only mids that will be top 10 end of year. At least one more legit premium needed in the mids.

[RaisyDaisy]

I reckon the strength in my fwd/back will pick up anyone that lacks behind in my mids.

Strength in your fwd and def? Sorry, but I don't see any strength there, well no where near enough to make up from not having Gaz/Pendles etc

Love the idea of going with POD and breakout contenders but all lines seem a bit weak to me

One of Gaz/Pendles is a must, and I would get rid of Jacobs, Dixon and McKenzie too, much better options in those spots

[AaronKirk]

Some risk here... ok there is a LOT of risk here.

Def: Will Ibbo and McKenzie be top 10 defenders at years end? No. They need to be upgraded to the likes of Hibberd, Simpson etc- S.Mitchell a better pick than Walker at the price

Mid: rookies are ok at this stage but premos need work. Keep 2 of the mids you picked (Beams and one other) and upgrade the rest to proven premos.

Ruck: Upgrade Jacobs please

Fwd: T.Mitch could be worth the risk but there are cheaper options such as Pav/Gunston/Zorko who will outscore him- Buddy for Dixon?

Lot to work on here.

[Doggoneit]

I reckon the strength in my fwd/back will pick up anyone that lacks behind in my mids.

Strength in your fwd and def? Sorry, but I don't see any strength there, well no where near enough to make up from not having Gaz/Pendles etc

Love the idea of going with POD and breakout contenders but all lines seem a bit weak to me

One of Gaz/Pendles is a must, and I would get rid of Jacobs, Dixon and McKenzie too, much better options in those spots

+1

[Johnahawk]

You need more super premiums, and lots of them!

[Bennny]

Come on mate, start from scratch !

[aussied]

before NAB cup i was really looking forward of having dixon as DPP, however have totally jumped off, better of with hale.

[HotTiges]

def: A.Walker, J.Mcveigh, G.Ibbotson, T.Mckenzie, L.Mcdonald, M.Fuller (J.Tippett,T.Cutler)

mid: J.Steven, T.Liberatore, N.Fyfe, D.Beams, B.Ellis, J.Martin, J.Aish, V.Michie (T.Langdon, M.Honey-Church)

ruc: S.Jacobs, A.Sandilands (D.Currie, T.Derickx)

fwd: P.Dangerfield, D.Martin, C.Dixon, T.Mitchell, J.Lamb, J.Hogan (D.Garlett, J.Kennedy-Harris)

$2,600 cap left
rates and opinions pleaseee

It's different that's for sure.

Def - no mid price value.(suckling, shaw, griffiths etc..)no Fuller again in digs squad.JTip on rookie list but could be upgraded I think.

Mid - Wow, no Gaz or Pendles and you would need Martin and someone else to have a OMeara like season and Gaz/Pendles to,drop a bucket load..good luck.Like the Brandon Ellis pick.Hope he has a monster year.

Rucks - Jacobs? Does nothing around the ground and relies on tap work.Id pick someone else.

Fwd - Mitchell looks a gun.watch him again and see if he backs it up.Jed Lamb isn't a super pick.Haven't really seen much at all from him.you don't to be relying him for a score.Hogan a future star but usual doubts as a young KPP.Garlett unknown..where is he?

[westy501]

Come on mate, start from scratch !

do it!

[greco272]

Come on mate, start from scratch !

2nd that