This one or that?

[Ricochet]

Got to ask the Sydney question:
Parker vs Mitchell.

Titch because he's a Claremont boy :P he scored 40 points more in NAB 1, isn't that a solid indicator? Both had similar TOG stats

Guess I just see titch spending more time forward when the big mids come back

who was missing? Jack, Hanners, ROK, McVeigh and JPK all played

Parker and TMitch attended more centre bounces then these guys. I don't think that will be the case come round 1

[Matt_352]

Tom Mitchell & Matthew Wright V Lance Franklin & Matthew Pavlich

Suckling V Haynes

Clurey V Cutler V Ashby V Fuller V Laidler for bottom 2 back spots

Currie V Thurlow

Sam Lloyd V Rohan V Bock V Kersten V Markworth

[stew42]

Tom Mitchell & Matthew Wright V Lance Franklin & Matthew Pavlich
Titch and Matthew Wright are a bit hyped from NAB. Whilst Titch is a gun and is in the best 22, the same can't be said for Wrighty. And Pavlich is not guaranteed to lift his average to the 90s. So ideally Titch and Buddy, but the combos themselves aren't great.

Suckling V Haynes
Suckling just because we know he can average 80's to 90s. It's a lot more of a gamble with Haynes, but he'd be a good upgrade target if he fires.

Clurey V Cutler V Ashby V Fuller V Laidler for bottom 2 back spots
In my opinion, Fuller and Laidler. But Georgiou has also got a bit of hype (rookie elevation pending)

Currie vs Thurlow
Thurlow is more likely to get games early, but won't get any game time when Belly comes back. Currie might get games, might not. Most of us thought he'd get a go last year, but didn't. There is a spot there if he can get it.

Lloyd v Rohan v Bock v Kersten v Markworth
In order of JS
1. Bock
2. Rohan
3. Kersten
4. Markworth
5. Lloyd
Bock also has highest scoring potential imo. Just depends on cash for you

[stew42]

Watson or Masten???

[Adamant]

Watson or Masten???

Jobe. Proven, underpriced and a top bloke.

[Money]

Watson or Masten???

Masten for me, seriously think he can get up to that premium status and super unqiue

[Money]

Caddy and Fasolo or Higgins and Lamb?

[stew42]

Caddy Fasolo, I reckon. Anyone but Higgins (although I have him in my Rnd 1 team ;) )

This is for RDT, so don't worry about price:
JMartin, Michie or CBeams?

[dirkdiggler]

Caddy Fasolo, I reckon. Anyone but Higgins (although I have him in my Rnd 1 team ;) )

This is for RDT, so don't worry about price:
JMartin, Michie or CBeams?

Michie comfortably I think...he will thrive under Roos and think he has a higher ceiling than the others

[Junkitup]

Caddy Fasolo, I reckon. Anyone but Higgins (although I have him in my Rnd 1 team ;) )

This is for RDT, so don't worry about price:
JMartin, Michie or CBeams?

Michie comfortably I think...he will thrive under Roos and think he has a higher ceiling than the others

+1 Michie

Tyson v Dunstan

Betts v Higgins v Dahlhaus

TMitchell v Monfries

[blues boy]

Caddy Fasolo, I reckon. Anyone but Higgins (although I have him in my Rnd 1 team ;) )

This is for RDT, so don't worry about price:
JMartin, Michie or CBeams?

Michie comfortably I think...he will thrive under Roos and think he has a higher ceiling than the others

+1 Michie

Tyson v Dunstan

Betts v Higgins v Dahlhaus

TMitchell v Monfries

Tyson i think he has slightly better JS and also his scoring ability is better

Higgins as betts and dahlhaus can both go missing in games and do rely heavily on kicking goals to score well, where higgins can actually find the ball regularly

Mitchell by a country mile

[blues boy]

D. Swan and L. Dunstan with 190K left in the bank

or

T. Cotchin and T. Libba with 4K left in the bank

Current Midfield: Swan, Rocky, Watson, D. Beams, D. Thomas, L. Dunstan, D. Tyson, C. Beams (J. Polec and X. Ellis)

Cheers guys

[Ricochet]

D. Swan and L. Dunstan with 190K left in the bank

or

T. Cotchin and T. Libba with 4K left in the bank

Current Midfield: Swan, Rocky, Watson, D. Beams, D. Thomas, L. Dunstan, D. Tyson, C. Beams (J. Polec and X. Ellis)

Cheers guys

Swan and Dunstan mate.
Swan will give you regular captaincy scores and Dunstan will generate some decent cash. Maybe go Michie over Dunstan though.

[smoothM24]

Deledio v Redden

[pommyadam]

Deledio v Redden

Cotchin?
but considering that isn't a choice, Redden due to the non-rd8 bye