This one or that?

[stew42]

Ok, I'm gonna try something here, just to put it all in the one thread:

Put down your "Which would you rather"s below. RULE: You cannot put up yours until the one above you is answered. Bonus brownie points if you add projected averages or some reasoning behind your choice

I'll kick it off:
Pendles and Daisy
or
Marc Murphy and Ziebell

This would be for Rnd 1 only.

[Artax]

Think it is irrelevant for round 1 only but I would still take Pendles & Daisy.. both in my side. I will be chasing Pendles with my first pick in draft leagues this season.

I am debating Waton & Jack Martin or Brandon Ellis & Savage

[Jukes]

Think it is irrelevant for round 1 only but I would still take Pendles & Daisy.. both in my side. I will be chasing Pendles with my first pick in draft leagues this season.

I am debating Waton & Jack Martin or Brandon Ellis & Savage

I'm a big fan of all four players, it'll be very close but I reckon Watto and Martin just edges out, less risk involved- not praying for a breakout.


Ellis and Swallow or Cotch and KKolodjashnij?

[pommyadam]

given that KKolo hasn't been named for NAB1, probably the former (but can't you afford the 40k to make him Smurphy/Zaha?)

Harvey and Darling, or Parker and Pav?

[Jukes]

given that KKolo hasn't been named for NAB1, probably the former (but can't you afford the 40k to make him Smurphy/Zaha?)

Harvey and Darling, or Parker and Pav?

I'm seriously considering Zacka over Ellis, going to wait and see if he can score well with Watto and Goddard in the team...also having three bombers mids could be tricky :3


Parker and Pav, certainly. I'll be picking Lecca and JJK before Darling, but I won't be picking any of them, and Boomer is about to check into the retirement home :P

[blues boy]

Not sure out of Ablett, Pav/Franklin and Fuller/Laidler or Rocky, Caddy, D. Swallow

[zeus123456]

Franklin and Chapman or Pav and Parker. Think carefully

[Jukes]

Not sure out of Ablett, Pav/Franklin and Fuller/Laidler or Rocky, Caddy, D. Swallow

The second one, easily. Would still look to get in Buddy though.

Franklin and Chapman or Pav and Parker. Think carefully

Buddy and Gunston? :P would lean towards option (a)

[Ricochet]

Franklin and Chapman or Pav and Parker. Think carefully

Buddy and Chappy mate. Buddy will be back to his best this year and Chappy will easily beat Parker. Just be careful that Chappy has mentioned he will get a few rests this year.

[Jukes]

Dusty and Chappy
Libba and Chappy
Cotch and Chappy
or
Daisy and Dusty?

i.e. Dusty/Libba/Cotch and Chappy or Daisy and Dusty

[Ricochet]

Dusty and Chappy
Libba and Chappy
Cotch and Chappy
or
Daisy and Dusty?

i.e. Dusty/Libba/Cotch and Chappy or Daisy and Dusty

I'd go Daisy and Dusty mate. As much as I love the Chappy pick, Dusty has a super easy draw this year and Daisy is to much value to pass up

[Jukes]

Dusty and Chappy
Libba and Chappy
Cotch and Chappy
or
Daisy and Dusty?

i.e. Dusty/Libba/Cotch and Chappy or Daisy and Dusty

I'd go Daisy and Dusty mate. As much as I love the Chappy pick, Dusty has a super easy draw this year and Daisy is to much value to pass up

Thanks, I was probably leaning towards that one. It makes my forward line insane- Dusty, Wingard, Buddy, Gunston, Zorko, Caddy :3

[Ricochet]

Dusty and Chappy
Libba and Chappy
Cotch and Chappy
or
Daisy and Dusty?

i.e. Dusty/Libba/Cotch and Chappy or Daisy and Dusty

I'd go Daisy and Dusty mate. As much as I love the Chappy pick, Dusty has a super easy draw this year and Daisy is to much value to pass up

Thanks, I was probably leaning towards that one. It makes my forward line insane- Dusty, Wingard, Buddy, Gunston, Zorko, Caddy :3

flower me that's strong. Not jumping on some of the value picks in the fwd line?

[Jukes]

I see Caddy as a value pick :P and a potential super star

Zorko too to an extent, priced at 74 but should be 90+ if his role is the same as against the hawks, maybe even 100+

The rest of my team is quite tight ass, 4 premos + Daisy and Savage in the midfield, 3 premos + Swallow, Koloj and Luke Mac down back.

[blues boy]

Can match you there i reckon jukes with my forward line:

Danger, dusty, buddy, pav, caddy and lamb