Please rate my team ver 1.0

[geoffmack]

G'day peeps, second crack at supercoach, lemme know your honest thoughts. Thanks.

Mitchell, Hanley, Everitt, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald, (cutler, fuller)

GAJ, Pendles, Boak, Cotchin, Murphy, Beams,  Daisy, J. Martin, (dunstan, Robertson)

Grundy, Sandy, (thurlow, nankervis)

Danger, Dixon, Buddy, Rohan, Garlet, Honeychurch, (apeness, Kennedy-Harris)

Salary: $159,300

[nperera95]

def: Too weak. I've seen a few teams with Everitt now...dont get sucked in! hahaha. McDonald definitely a lock.
mid: You know you've spent way too much on the midfield when you have J.Martin at M8. Most team have him at M6. IMO, i would get rid of Boak and Murphy for good quality rookies like Sheed, C.Beams, Aish.
mid: risky ruck but if it does work out well, then congrats for taking that risk.
fwd: too weak. Would want Rohan F5, not at F4. Like the Dixon pick.

overall: Need to work on defense and forward more. Spend less on the mids and then use that cash plus the $159,300 for your def and fwd. good luck :)

[nick wilkesmann]

I'd spend your extra cash getting in a legitimate top 4 ruck! take a punt on your r2

[geoffmack]

def: Too weak. I've seen a few teams with Everitt now...dont get sucked in! hahaha. McDonald definitely a lock.
mid: You know you've spent way too much on the midfield when you have J.Martin at M8. Most team have him at M6. IMO, i would get rid of Boak and Murphy for good quality rookies like Sheed, C.Beams, Aish.
mid: risky ruck but if it does work out well, then congrats for taking that risk.
fwd: too weak. Would want Rohan F5, not at F4. Like the Dixon pick.

overall: Need to work on defense and forward more. Spend less on the mids and then use that cash plus the $159,300 for your def and fwd. good luck :)

Yep you right re Everitt, truth be told I had Atley but after his spud showing I dumped him!! Have replaced him with McVeigh with R10 bye and Cotch OUT, X Ellis IN, Garlett OUT, Caddy IN.

[geoffmack]

Updated team as follows:

Mitchell, Hanley, McVeigh, Suckling, Kolodjashnij, McDonald, (cutler, fuller)

GAJ, Pendles, Boak, Murphy, Beams, Daisy, J. Martin, X. Ellis (dunstan, Robertson)

Grundy, Sandy, (thurlow, nankervis)

Danger, Dixon, Buddy, Caddy, Rohan, Honeychurch, (Apeness, Kennedy-Harris)

Salary: $133,700

Apeness in the FWD line is NAB challenge form pending, tossing him up with Garlett if he plays.

[tor01doc]

Only need one of Apeness / Thurlow at R4.

Get a better guy for F6 - Higgins!!

[geoffmack]

Only need one of Apeness / Thurlow at R4.

Get a better guy for F6 - Higgins!!

Higgins really?? Hmmmmm interesting.