Murphy and Caddy vs Rockliff and Bock.

[Jackross10]

It is

Ablett Pendles Murphy Beams Martin Michie Sheed Ellis.      Dunstan Robertson.
Danger Martin Buddy Pav Caddy KennedyHarris.      Kersten Impey.

Or

Ablett Pendles Rockliff Beams Martin Mochie Sheed Ellis.      Dunstan Robertson.
Danger Martin Buddy Pav Bock KennedyHarris.     Kersten Impey.

Thanks.

[Rabid Hamster]

It is

Ablett Pendles Murphy Beams Martin Michie Sheed Ellis.      Dunstan Robertson.
Danger Martin Buddy Pav Caddy KennedyHarris.      Kersten Impey.

Or

Ablett Pendles Rockliff Beams Martin Mochie Sheed Ellis.      Dunstan Robertson.
Danger Martin Buddy Pav Bock KennedyHarris.     Kersten Impey.

Thanks.

I would go Michie over Mochie. Michie is getting quite a bit of possession and had good stats last year, whereas Mochie is more of a fringe player and can't get his own ball.

[Bully]

Bock is a wait and see proposition, if he's ok by round 1 then he's too cheap to ignore. But i still like Murphy, maybe you could use the extra 100k on you defence or ruck division?

[Grufflez]

Bock has been broken.Bock will break again.Bock can't be fixed.

[Jackross10]

McVeigh Simpson Enright Birchall Suckling LMac.   Cutler Fuller
Ablett Pendles Murphy Beams Martin Michie Sheed Ellis.      Dunstan Robertson.
Naitanui Sandi.    Nankervis king (Loophole)
Danger Martin Buddy Pav Caddy KennedyHarris.      Kersten Impey.

This is my team at the moment. 20k. So don't know what to do?

[Bully]

Backline looks great, maybe there's a case to upgrade Birch to Mitchell but that's personal preference.

Mids also look solid, you've got the pick of the rookies IMO.

Rucks look good but get a DPP player in there, a Brown & King combo will give you just about every Sunday game on offer.

Forwards also good, Caddy will almost certainly increase in price. Mine's the same only I have sacrificed Jack Martin to get Hawkins in there, I just think he's the one guy who could separate you from the crowd (provided he keeps his form up).

The joker in the pack is Naitanui, if he doesn't get up what's the plan?

[Jackross10]

Backline looks great, maybe there's a case to upgrade Birch to Mitchell but that's personal preference.

Mids also look solid, you've got the pick of the rookies IMO.

Rucks look good but get a DPP player in there, a Brown & King combo will give you just about every Sunday game on offer.

Forwards also good, Caddy will almost certainly increase in price. Mine's the same only I have sacrificed Jack Martin to get Hawkins in there, I just think he's the one guy who could separate you from the crowd (provided he keeps his form up).

The joker in the pack is Naitanui, if he doesn't get up what's the plan?

Thanks mate. If nic doesn't get up. I'll be getting Lobbe and the. I could use the cash to get in Mitchell or Birchall maybe! Thanks a lot tho man :)

[Grufflez]

McVeigh Simpson Enright Birchall Suckling LMac.   Cutler Fuller
Ablett Pendles Murphy Beams Martin Michie Sheed Ellis.      Dunstan Robertson.
Naitanui Sandi.    Nankervis king (Loophole)
Danger Martin Buddy Pav Caddy KennedyHarris.      Kersten Impey.

This is my team at the moment. 20k. So don't know what to do?

Nice team only concern is the rucks risk of injury.

[Bully]

McVeigh Simpson Enright Birchall Suckling LMac.   Cutler Fuller
Ablett Pendles Murphy Beams Martin Michie Sheed Ellis.      Dunstan Robertson.
Naitanui Sandi.    Nankervis king (Loophole)
Danger Martin Buddy Pav Caddy KennedyHarris.      Kersten Impey.

This is my team at the moment. 20k. So don't know what to do?

Nice team only concern is the rucks risk of injury.

This is the problem we're all grappling with, my plan is to trade in Dixon if it's a short term injury, or just trade out both R1 or R2 if it's longterm. Not ideal but I can't bring myself to leave 200k festering on the bench.

[Ringo]

Not impressed with Murphys effort last night - will need to really show something in the next games to warrant inclusion.

[Jimmykidd]

Not impressed with Murphys effort last night - will need to really show something in the next games to warrant inclusion.

Yes! I'm a Carlton fan and to me he looked really average to be honest. Did not expect that at all. I know it's only NAB but still it was very poor. Looked slow and disinterested. Watch VERY closely from now on.

[GoLions]

I'm surprised at the results of the poll so far. If Bock goes ok in the pre-season and is named round 1, he is an absolute lock for me, and personally I see Rocky being a top 8 mid at the end of the year. Murphy is in that awkward price range as he's not going to make enough money to be used as a cash cow, and I'm not sure if he'll score high enough to be a keeper. M9 spot maybe, but I don't think I'd want him as one of my 8 mids at the end of the season.

[Jackross10]

I'm surprised at the results of the poll so far. If Bock goes ok in the pre-season and is named round 1, he is an absolute lock for me, and personally I see Rocky being a top 8 mid at the end of the year. Murphy is in that awkward price range as he's not going to make enough money to be used as a cash cow, and I'm not sure if he'll score high enough to be a keeper. M9 spot maybe, but I don't think I'd want him as one of my 8 mids at the end of the season.

Yeah I agree. I have Watson > Rocky atm. What you think

[GoLions]

I'm surprised at the results of the poll so far. If Bock goes ok in the pre-season and is named round 1, he is an absolute lock for me, and personally I see Rocky being a top 8 mid at the end of the year. Murphy is in that awkward price range as he's not going to make enough money to be used as a cash cow, and I'm not sure if he'll score high enough to be a keeper. M9 spot maybe, but I don't think I'd want him as one of my 8 mids at the end of the season.

Yeah I agree. I have Watson > Rocky atm. What you think

Watson and Rocky I'm predicting to average about the same, so basically your call there. Both I think should be top 8 mids

[mzunguman]

Have you considered Boak as a POD? Only had a handful of less than 90 games and has a high ceiling....